01
Best overall pick
Ada Padrone's
Downtown Ada On South Main Street • Classic Small-Town Pizzeria • Go-To Spot For Big, Shareable Pies
Ada Padrone's serves generously topped, straightforward pizzas that hit the comfort‑food sweet spot for students and locals alike.
This is the kind of place where a large pepperoni and a couple of pitchers can easily feed a whole table after a game or rehearsal. The crust leans classic Midwestern—sturdy enough to hold plenty of cheese and toppings without getting fussy about it. It’s casual, affordable, and reliably satisfying, which is exactly why it’s many residents’ first answer when you ask where to get pizza in Ada.
02
Coziest dine-in option
Viva Maria
Corner Of Main Street And Lincoln Avenue In Ada • Sit-Down Italian Restaurant With Pizza • Best For Lingering Dinners
Viva Maria pairs hearty, oven‑baked pizzas with a full Italian menu and a relaxed, linger‑as‑long‑as‑you-like atmosphere.
If you want pizza but don’t necessarily want a pizza joint, Viva Maria is where you book a booth. Their pies come with a slightly thicker, chewy crust and plenty of sauce, alongside classics like pasta, chicken parm, and garlic bread. It’s an easy pick for date night, visiting parents, or anyone who wants a glass of wine and a proper sit‑down meal with their pizza.
03
Most convenient for takeout
East of Chicago Pizza
Near The Ohio Northern University Campus In Ada • Carryout And Delivery Pizza Chain Outpost • Best For Game Nights And Groups
East of Chicago’s Ada location turns out thick, saucy pizzas, subs, and wings that are tailor‑made for takeout, delivery, and late‑night study sessions.
Known for its pan and deep‑dish styles, this spot is all about hearty, cheesy slices that can feed a crowd without breaking the bank. Students lean on it for dorm deliveries, but it’s just as handy for local families who want an easy dinner after a long day. The menu is broad—think specialty pies, breadsticks, and party‑size orders—so it works well when everyone in the group wants something a little different.
04
Best nearby road-trip pie
Michael Angelo's Pizza
Downtown Kenton, About 15–20 Minutes South Of Ada • Old-School Regional Pizza Shop • Worth-The-Drive Classic
Michael Angelo's in Kenton serves thin‑to‑medium crust pizzas with a loyal following, making it a common out‑of‑town stop for Ada residents.
If you’re up for a short drive, this long‑running shop in Kenton rewards you with crisp‑edged crusts, well‑seasoned sauce, and that slightly nostalgic, hometown‑pizza feel. Locals talk up the classic pepperoni and the loaded specialty pies, which arrive hot and cut into party squares. It’s the kind of place where the staff likely recognizes regulars, and where many families from around Hardin County have their go‑to Friday‑night order.
05
Heaviest-hitting slices
Fat Jack's Pizza
East Side Of Lima, About 25 Minutes West Of Ada • Casual Local Chain Known For Thick, Cheesy Pies • Best For Big Appetites
Fat Jack's in Lima piles on the toppings and cheese, turning out heavy, indulgent pizzas ideal for serious hunger or sharing with a crew.
When you want a pizza that feels like a full meal and then some, Fat Jack’s is worth the drive from Ada. Their crust tends to be on the thicker side, built to handle generous layers of cheese, sauce, and toppings without collapsing. Pair a specialty pie with their breadsticks or wings and you’ve got an easy, no‑frills feast for game days, team celebrations, or road‑trip carb loading.