01
Best overall pick
Steve's Pizza
Adelphi Village Center • Small-Town Carryout Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A no-frills Adelphi staple turning out generously topped, classic Ohio-style pies.
If you ask around Adelphi where to grab a pizza without leaving the village, Steve’s is the name you’ll hear. The menu leans into familiar favorites—pepperoni, sausage, and loaded deluxe combinations—with a slightly thicker crust that holds up well for takeout. It’s the kind of spot where calling in an order feels like a routine locals have had for years.
02
Worth the drive to Logan
Pizza Crossing
Downtown Logan • Lively Family Pizzeria • Best For Groups
Beloved in Hocking County for its hefty toppings, chewy crust, and bustling dine-in vibe.
Pizza Crossing in Logan is a go-to for Adelphi folks heading toward Hocking Hills or running errands in town. Expect big, shareable pies with plenty of cheese and toppings, plus subs and wings to round out a group order. It’s busy on weekends, but that buzz is part of the charm, especially if you’re dining in with family or friends.
03
Classic tavern-style stop
Cardo's Pizza & Tavern
Circleville • Classic Ohio Tavern-Style Pizza • Best For Pizza And A Pint
Thin, crispy-edged squares and a laid-back bar setting make this Circleville mainstay worth the short trip.
Cardo’s in Circleville offers the old-school tavern experience many Central Ohioans grew up with: pizzas cut into squares, cold beer, and plenty of locals. The crust is thinner here, with a satisfying crunch under plenty of toppings. It’s an easy choice when you want more of an evening out than a quick carryout run from Adelphi.
04
For wood-fired fans
Fire & Stone Pizzeria
Downtown Chillicothe • Brick-Oven Neapolitan-Style Spot • Best For Date Night
Hand-crafted, wood-fired pies and a historic downtown setting give this Chillicothe shop a more polished feel.
Fire & Stone leans into a different style than most nearby spots, with blistered, chewy crusts and thoughtfully paired toppings. It’s the kind of place where you’ll find specialty combinations alongside a good beer or wine list, making it a nice upgrade from standard takeout. Pair a pizza with a stroll around Chillicothe’s historic streets and it becomes a full evening out from Adelphi.
05
Reliable nearby chain
Giovanni's Pizza
Kingston • Casual Hometown Chain • Best For Carryout From Kingston
A regional favorite turning out consistent pies, subs, and salads just a short hop from Adelphi.
Giovanni’s in Kingston is a practical choice when you’re on the west side of Adelphi and need something everyone will agree on. The crust is a touch thicker, with a slightly sweet sauce that has its own fan base across southern Ohio. With pizzas, stromboli, and family-friendly pricing, it’s an easy weeknight solution that still feels like a treat.