01
Best hometown staple
Pizza Stop Thru
Just Off Washington Road In Albany • Drive-Thru Pizzeria And Comfort-Food Spot • Local Favorite
A no-frills drive-thru that turns out surprisingly solid pizzas alongside classic small-town comfort food.
Pizza Stop Thru is the kind of place where locals know the staff by name and grab a pizza on the way home without getting out of the car. The crust is straightforward and sturdy, with plenty of cheese and toppings, and the menu leans into hearty, familiar flavors. It is especially handy on busy weeknights or after a game, when convenience matters as much as the pie.
02
Most creative pies
Avalanche Pizza
West Side Of Athens • Artisanal, Topping-Heavy Pizzeria • Destination For Food Lovers
Inventive, generously topped pizzas with a big personality that draws fans from all over Athens County.
Avalanche Pizza is known for piling on bold toppings, playful flavor combos, and crust that manages to be both chewy and crisp. The menu ranges from classic pepperoni to wild specials with house-made sauces, fresh veggies, and gourmet meats. It is the place you drive into Athens for when you want pizza to feel like an event rather than just a quick bite.
03
Best for families
Pizza Cottage
East State Street Strip In Athens • Casual Family-Friendly Pizzeria • Group-Friendly Choice
A roomy, family-oriented spot with reliable pies, shareable appetizers, and plenty of space for teams and groups.
Pizza Cottage offers a broad selection of pizzas, from thin to thicker bakes, with crowd-pleasing toppings and an approachable sauce. The dining room is comfortable and easygoing, making it a natural choice for birthday parties, youth teams, or a casual night out. It is also a solid option when you want pizza plus wings, salads, and other familiar sides without driving all over town.
04
Classic college-town slice
Mama Rosa's Pizza
Near The Ohio University Campus In Athens • Old-School Takeout And Late-Night Pizza Shop • Best For A Casual Slice
A long-running Athens standby serving straightforward, cheesy pies that hit the spot after a game or concert.
Mama Rosa's leans into the classic college-town formula: big pies, plenty of cheese, and a relaxed, slightly scruffy vibe. The crust is soft and foldable, great for grabbing a quick slice on the go or sharing a box back at home. It is not fancy, but it is part of the Athens routine for many students and locals, especially when the evening runs late.
05
Worth the short drive
Plus One Pizza
The Plains, North Of Athens • Small-Town Carryout And Delivery Shop • Best For Customizable Orders
A nearby chain outpost where you can load up your pizza exactly how you like it and carry it back to Albany still hot.
Plus One Pizza in The Plains is popular for its build-it-your-way approach, with lots of topping choices and several crust options. The pizzas lean hearty, with generous cheese and sauce that appeals to those who like a classic Ohio-style pie. It is an easy stop when you are already headed toward Athens and want something you can bring home to feed a group.