01
Best overall pick
Johnston's Lakehouse Pizza
Alexandria Village Center • Casual Small-Town Pizzeria And Sub Shop • Go-To Choice In Alexandria
Cozy and straightforward, this village favorite turns out fresh, no-fuss pies with plenty of topping options.
If you want pizza without leaving Alexandria, this is the spot locals rely on. The dough is made fresh and the menu goes beyond pies to include subs, wings, and salads, which makes it easy to please everyone in the group. Call ahead on busy evenings, as the kitchen can get slammed with takeout orders.
02
Old-school favorite
Plaza Pizza Johnstown
Downtown Johnstown • No-Frills Carryout And Delivery Pizzeria • Worth The Short Drive
A classic small-town pizza joint known for generous cheese, a slightly sweet sauce, and quick, friendly service.
Just a quick drive west of Alexandria, Plaza Pizza is the kind of place people grow up with and keep coming back to. Expect well-loaded pies, crispy crust, and a menu that covers all the comfort basics, from pepperoni to meat lovers. It’s primarily a takeout and delivery operation, perfect when you want a reliable, hot pizza without lingering over a sit-down meal.
03
Easy crowd-pleaser
Donatos Pizza Granville
Granville Main Street Corridor • Regional Ohio Chain With Thin-Crust Specialty • Best For Big Groups
Crisp, edge-to-edge topping coverage and consistent quality make this a safe bet for feeding a crowd.
Donatos is an Ohio staple, and the Granville location is convenient for Alexandria families and teams coming through town. The signature thin crust and “edge-to-edge” toppings keep each slice light but flavorful, and there are plenty of options for salads, wings, and subs on the side. It’s especially handy for large orders after games, practices, or school events.
04
Classic Ohio-style choice
Christy's Pizza
West Newark • Homegrown Central Ohio Pizza Chain • Best For Classic Ohio-Style Pies
Square-cut pies with a sturdy crust and nostalgic flavor profile make this a standby for many Licking County families.
Christy’s is one of those low-key Ohio chains that feels more local than corporate, and Newark is the nearest outpost for Alexandria. The crust runs on the thicker side of Ohio-style, with plenty of cheese and toppings sliced into easy-to-share squares. It’s a solid option when you’re craving something familiar and filling on the west side of Newark.
05
Family night staple
Pizza Cottage
South Newark Shopping Strip • Lively Sit-Down Pizzeria With A Full Menu • Best Dine-In Experience
A bigger dining room, arcade-style fun, and loaded pies make this a natural pick for pizza nights out.
Pizza Cottage gives you more of an outing than a quick pickup, which is great when you want to make an evening of it after the drive from Alexandria. The pizzas lean hearty, with thick layers of cheese and crowd-pleasing specialty combinations, plus appetizers and salads that can easily fill a table. It’s a popular choice for birthday parties, team celebrations, and family dinners when everyone’s in the mood for pizza.