01
Best overall pick
Ciao Pizza
Ada Main Street • Family-Run Pizzeria • Local Favorite For All-Around Pizza Night
Lively Ada mainstay serving big, foldable pies that hit the spot after work or a ONU game.
Ciao Pizza is the kind of small-town shop where the crust has a little chew, the cheese is generous, and the toppings are piled on without fuss. It is a go-to for Alger and Ada locals alike, especially when you want something more personal than a chain. Call ahead on weekend evenings; the orders stack up fast on game nights and during campus events.
02
Best for big groups
East of Chicago Pizza
Near Ohio Northern University • Buffet-Style Pizza Spot • Best For Groups And Casual Meetups
A flexible option near campus with thick-crust pizzas, wings, and deals that work well for feeding a crowd.
If you are rolling in with a team, study group, or extended family, East of Chicago in Ada makes it easy to cover everyone. Their signature pan crust and pile-on toppings give you that hearty, Midwestern pizza feel, and the menu runs deep with subs, wedges, and wings. It is a short hop from Alger and a practical choice when you care more about plenty of food than white-tablecloth ambiance.
03
Classic hometown pick
Michael Angelo's Pizza
Downtown Kenton • Old-School Carryout Joint • Best For Classic Carryout
Long-running Kenton shop known for its crisp, edge-to-edge toppings and dependable carryout pies.
Michael Angelo's in Kenton feels like the textbook small-town pizza place, complete with a loyal local following and recipes that have barely changed in years. The pizzas lean toward a thinner crust with plenty of toppings right out to the edge, making each slice feel substantial. It is an easy stop when you are already in Kenton running errands and want a sure-thing box to bring back to Alger.
04
Worth the drive
Fat Jack's Pizza
West Lima Corridor • Creative Regional Chain • Best For Loaded Specialty Pies
Regional favorite in Lima slinging heavily topped specialty pizzas that justify the extra miles from Alger.
When you are in the mood to make pizza the whole reason for a trip, Fat Jack's in Lima is a smart target. Their specialty combinations, from meat-heavy options to veggie-forward pies, are stacked with toppings and built on a crust that stays sturdy under the weight. Pair a large pie with their cheesy breadsticks, and you have an easy weekend outing that feels a bit bigger than your usual carryout.
05
Most familiar choice
Pizza Hut
Ada Highway Strip • Classic National Chain • Reliable Family Standby
A familiar Ada stop where families from Alger can grab pan pizza, pasta, and wings without overthinking it.
The Ada Pizza Hut may not be a hidden gem, but it absolutely fills a niche for families who want something predictable and kid-friendly. The menu covers the classics, from stuffed crust and pan pizzas to breadsticks and simple pasta, and the service is tuned for quick in-and-out pickup. It is especially handy on busy weeknights when cooking is off the table and you just need a dependable option on the way through town.