Amanda may be a small village, but it punches above its weight when it comes to pizza, with a couple of beloved locals and several strong options a short drive away. Whether you want a quick carryout pie after a ballgame or a sit-down meal with the family in Lancaster, you’ll find plenty of crust styles and topping combos to keep everyone happy. Use this list as a starting point for your next night out or low-key takeout run.
A go-to Amanda staple for generously topped pies and fast, friendly carryout.
Cristy's sits right on Main Street, making it an easy stop for weeknight dinners or post-game slices. The pizzas lean hearty, with plenty of cheese and toppings, and the crust holds up well on the drive home. Round it out with breadsticks or wings and you’ve got an easy win for feeding a crowd without leaving town.
Formerly Tommy Wayne’s, this spot keeps the local tradition alive with loaded pizzas, subs, and wings.
Carrying on the legacy of Tommy Wayne’s, Amanda House of Cards is the kind of place where locals linger over a pie and a basket of wings. The menu is broad for a small-town shop, with subs, salads, and plenty of topping combos if you like to customize. It’s an easy choice when you want a relaxed hangout just outside the village center.
A short drive from Amanda, Pizza Cottage offers roomy seating, consistent pies, and a big menu that works for mixed tastes.
If you’re heading into Lancaster and want to sit down for a proper meal, Pizza Cottage is an easy crowd-pleaser. The crust is on the thicker, chewier side, with plenty of classic and specialty pizzas plus salads and pasta for non-pizza folks. Spacious dining and a relaxed vibe make it especially good for families and team celebrations.
Known for its edge-to-edge toppings and crispy thin crust, Donatos is ideal when you’re ordering multiple pies for a crowd.
Donatos in Lancaster delivers the signature Ohio-style thin crust that cuts easily into squares for sharing. Toppings go right to the edge, so every piece feels like a “good slice,” and their predictable quality makes it a safe bet when you’re feeding a group. Pair a stack of pizzas with their salads and side orders for an uncomplicated group spread.
A Lancaster mainstay with substantial pies, cold drinks, and a relaxed, local-bar feel.
Fat Cat Pizza is a favorite when you want something a bit more old-school and low-key than the big chains. The pizzas are substantial, with a satisfying crust and plenty of classic toppings, and the atmosphere leans more toward a neighborhood bar than a quick-slice joint. It’s a solid option for an easy night out with friends after making the short drive in from Amanda.