01
Best overall pick
LaRosa's Pizzeria Amelia
Along Ohio Pike Near Central Amelia • Family-Friendly Cincinnati-Style Pizzeria • Go-To For Groups And Big Orders
A local standby for crowd-pleasing pies, pastas, and wings with plenty of booth space and reliable delivery.
LaRosa’s Amelia leans into the classic Cincinnati-style pizza experience, with a sweet-leaning sauce and plenty of topping combos that appeal to most tastes. It’s one of the most dependable options when you’re feeding a mixed crowd, from kids to in-laws, thanks to its broad menu and consistent delivery. Call ahead or order through their app on busy weekends if you want your pizza on time for kickoff.
02
Classic local favorite
Gramma's Pizza
Amelia Town Center Area • No-Frills Local Carryout Shop • Best For Classic, Hearty Pies
A straightforward, locally rooted pizza joint known for generous toppings and filling pies.
Gramma’s feels like the kind of place that has quietly kept Amelia fed for years: big pizzas, lots of cheese, and zero pretension. The crust is on the thicker, chewier side, making it ideal if you want something substantial rather than dainty slices. It’s primarily a carryout and delivery spot, so it’s perfect for low-key nights at home or casual gatherings.
03
Best for customizable pizzas
Marco's Pizza – State Route 125
State Route 125 Corridor • Chain Pizzeria With A Focus On Fresh Toppings • Great For Build-Your-Own Combinations
Offers well-seasoned sauce, good topping variety, and reliable delivery right off State Route 125.
Marco’s on State Route 125 stands out among chains for its flavorful sauce and above-average toppings, especially if you like to build your own combination. Their specialty pies, like the deluxe and meat-heavy options, are popular with families looking for something a bit more loaded. It’s a smart pick when you want consistency and easy online ordering after a long workday.
04
Comfort-chain classic
Pizza Hut – Amelia
East Ohio Pike Strip • Casual Chain Known For Pan And Stuffed-Crust Pizza • Best For Comfort Food Cravings
A familiar choice for thick, buttery pan pizza and wings, with late-evening hours that suit busy schedules.
The Pizza Hut on East Ohio Pike leans into what the brand does best: indulgent pan crusts, stuffed crust options, and plenty of sauces for wings. It’s especially handy when you’re looking for a later-night option or want those nostalgic flavors you grew up with. Pair a couple of specialty pies with an order of breadsticks and you’ve got an easy game-night spread.
05
Best value option
Little Caesars – Amelia
West Ohio Pike / Amelia–Olive Branch Area • Budget-Friendly Carryout Spot • Quick Grab-And-Go Choice
Known for its Hot-N-Ready pizzas and crazy bread, it’s the fastest way to grab multiple pies on a budget.
Little Caesars on West Ohio Pike is built for speed and value rather than lingering over a meal. The Hot-N-Ready model means you can often walk in and walk out with a couple of pepperoni or cheese pizzas in minutes, which is a lifesaver after practice or on hectic weeknights. Add an order of Crazy Bread or a Detroit-style deep dish if you want something a little more fun without stretching the budget.