01
Best overall pick
Old Towne Pizza
Historic Downtown Amherst • Classic Hometown Pizzeria With A Cozy Dining Room • Go-To Spot For A Sit-Down Pie
A beloved downtown staple turning out hearty, cheese-heavy pies in a laid-back, old-Amherst setting.
Old Towne Pizza feels like the place everyone in Amherst has a story about, from post-game team dinners to casual Friday nights. The pizza leans generous on toppings and cheese, with a crust that lands between soft and crisp, ideal for sharing a few different specialty pies. If you want the full small-town pizzeria experience with friendly service and time to linger, this is the place to start.
02
Best for pizza purists
D'Tutanelli's Pizza
Milan Avenue Corridor • Scratch-Dough Pizzeria With An Italian-Leaning Menu • Top Choice For Quality Ingredients
House-made dough and careful topping combos make these pies a step up from typical takeout.
D'Tutanelli's is known locally for taking the extra time with its crust, which comes out flavorful and sturdy enough to hold plenty of toppings without getting soggy. The menu mixes classic pepperoni and sausage with more Italian-inspired options, so you can keep it simple or branch out. It’s a strong pick when you care as much about the dough and sauce as you do about convenience.
03
Best family-run option
Jilliano's Pizzeria
East Side Amherst • Family-Owned Carry-Out And Delivery Shop • Ideal For Low-Key Dinners At Home
A neighborhood favorite for reliable, generously topped pizzas ready for pickup or delivery.
Jilliano’s Pizzeria keeps things straightforward: solid pies, fair prices, and friendly service from a family-run crew. The crust has a satisfying chew, and they don’t skimp on toppings, which makes their large pizzas a good value for feeding a crowd. It’s the kind of place locals call when they want a no-fuss pizza night without heading downtown.
04
Best chain-style variety
Marco's Pizza
North Amherst Shopping Area • National Chain With Customizable Pizzas And Sides • Great For Mixed-Order Groups
A flexible option where everyone can get their preferred crust, toppings, and add-ons in one order.
Marco’s gives you the predictability of a chain with plenty of ways to customize, from thin or classic crusts to specialty builds loaded with toppings. It’s especially handy when you’re ordering for a group that wants different combinations, plus wings or cheesy bread on the side. While it doesn’t try to be a sit-down destination, it hits the mark for quick, consistent carry-out or delivery.
05
Best late-night delivery backup
Papa Johns Pizza
Kresge Drive Retail Center • Delivery-Focused Chain With Familiar Favorites • Reliable Choice For Game Nights And Study Sessions
A dependable stop for classic chain pizza, garlic sauce, and sides when convenience is the priority.
Papa Johns in Amherst is all about fast, straightforward delivery with the same menu you’ll recognize from elsewhere. The crust is soft and sauce-forward, and the range of dipping sauces, breadsticks, and wings makes it easy to round out an order. It’s not trying to compete with the downtown parlors on ambiance, but when you want hot pizza at your door with minimal effort, it earns its spot in the rotation.