01
Iconic Ohio Valley slice
DiCarlo's Original Pizza
Downtown Steubenville, About 25 Minutes Southeast Of Amsterdam • Classic Ohio Valley Square-Cut Pizzeria • Local Legend
A must-try for the signature Ohio Valley style: crispy pan-baked crust, sauce baked in, and cheese sprinkled on after it comes out of the oven.
If you’re going to make one pizza pilgrimage from Amsterdam, DiCarlo’s is the classic choice. The simple menu focuses on their trademark square slices, with that addictive contrast of hot crust and cool toppings. Go for a tray to share and eat it while it’s fresh for the full local experience.
02
Neighborhood favorite
Giannamore's Pizza
Wintersville, West Of Steubenville On The Way From Amsterdam • Old-School Neighborhood Takeout Shop • Family Go-To
A long-running Wintersville staple known for its generous toppings, straightforward pies, and loyal local following.
Giannamore’s feels like the kind of pizza place every small town wishes it had. The crust runs on the thicker side with plenty of cheese, making it ideal for hearty, shareable orders. Call ahead on weekend evenings; locals know the drill and the rush can be real.
03
Customizable delivery pick
Domino's Pizza
Steubenville Commercial Strip Near Route 7 • National Delivery And Carryout Chain • Best For Fast Delivery
Reliable, fully customizable pizzas with lots of crust, sauce, and topping options, plus late-night delivery hours compared with most small-town spots.
When convenience matters as much as the pie itself, Domino’s in Steubenville is the dependable choice from Amsterdam. The online ordering and tracking make it easy to feed a group without leaving home, and you can tweak everything from crust style to sauce level. It’s especially handy for game nights or last-minute gatherings.
04
Sit-down chain option
Pizza Hut
Carrollton, Along The Main Commercial Strip • Casual Dine-In And Carryout Chain • Best For Families
Familiar pan and hand-tossed pies in a sit-down setting that’s easy for families making a grocery or errand run to Carrollton.
If you’re combining a trip to Carrollton with dinner, Pizza Hut offers an easy, predictable stop. The menu covers thick pan pizzas, stuffed crust, wings, and a few pastas, so even picky eaters can find something. It’s a comfortable option when you want a booth, refills, and a low-stress meal with kids in tow.
05
Game-day standby
Papa John’s Pizza
Steubenville, Hilltop Area Near Shopping And Campus • Carryout And Delivery Chain With Saucier Pies • Best For Big Groups
Saucy, topping-heavy pizzas with value-friendly bundle deals that work well when you’re feeding a crowd from Amsterdam.
For parties, team celebrations, or movie nights where you need several boxes on the table, Papa John’s in Steubenville is a practical pick. The crust leans soft and doughy, with plenty of cheese and that signature garlic dipping sauce on the side. Take advantage of online specials and mix in some breadsticks or wings to stretch the order further.