01
Best overall pick
Pizza Joes Andover
East Main Street In The Village • Classic Small-Town Pizzeria • Local Favorite
Your go-to Andover stop for dependable pies, subs, and wings right in the heart of town.
Pizza Joes is the spot most Andover locals name first when someone asks where to grab a pizza close by. The crust leans classic American, with plenty of cheese and straightforward toppings, plus sheet pizzas that work well for groups or lake weekends. Add in subs, wings, and friendly counter service, and it’s an easy choice when you want a no-fuss hometown slice.
02
Best pizza with a bar vibe
Andover Town Tavern
Near The Center Of Andover • Casual Tavern With Pizza And Pub Food • Best For Pizza And A Pint
A laid-back tavern where you can pair a hot pizza with cold drinks and live-at-the-bar conversation.
Andover Town Tavern is more than a watering hole; their kitchen turns out solid tavern-style pizzas alongside the usual pub favorites. Expect a crisp, cheesy pie that holds up well under hearty toppings, ideal for sharing over a game on TV. It’s the place to go when you want a relaxed night out rather than a quick grab-and-go slice.
03
Best family stop on the way home
Pizza Hut Orwell
Orwell, West Of Andover • Family-Friendly National Chain • Best For Families
A familiar sit-down spot where kids, adults, and picky eaters can all agree on pizza night.
About a 20-minute drive from Andover, the Orwell Pizza Hut is a reliable choice when you want a dine-in family pizza night. Pan pizzas, stuffed crust, and big orders of breadsticks make it easy to keep everyone at the table happy. It’s also convenient for carryout if you’re passing through Orwell on the way to or from Andover.
04
Best for loaded Ohio-style pies
Gionino's Pizzeria Jefferson
Jefferson, Northwest Of Andover • Ohio-Style Pizzeria With Big Toppings • Big-Flavor Takeout Pick
Known for garlic-heavy crust and generous toppings, this is the place when you want a loaded box of pizza.
Gionino’s in Jefferson is worth the drive from Andover if you like your pizza piled high. Their signature style features a slightly thicker crust brushed with garlic butter and plenty of cheese, plus crowd-pleasing specialty pies and jojo potatoes on the side. It’s a strong option for takeout when you’re feeding a crew or planning a game-day spread.
05
Best late-night delivery option
Domino's Pizza Jefferson
Jefferson, Near The Village Center • Fast-Delivery Chain Shop • Late-Night Pick
A dependable choice for customizable pizzas that show up fast when you don’t feel like cooking.
The Jefferson Domino’s serves much of the surrounding area and can be a practical option when you’re staying near Andover but still within their delivery range or passing through town. With online ordering, tracking, and lots of crust, sauce, and topping combinations, it’s easy to dial in exactly what everyone wants. It’s not a destination dining room, but for a quick, predictable pizza fix, it gets the job done.