01
Closest to Anna
Cassano's Pizza King
Jackson Center, Just West Of Anna • Classic Ohio Thin-Crust Carryout • Closest Hometown-Style Option
A no-frills Cassano's outpost serving the cracker-thin, square-cut pies many locals grew up on.
If you want pizza with minimal driving, this Jackson Center Cassano's is the go-to stop. Expect that signature ultra-thin crust, edge-to-edge toppings, and a sauce that leans pleasantly tangy. It’s set up mainly for takeout and quick bites, making it ideal for grabbing a couple of larges on the way home to Anna.
02
Classic sit-down pick
Amelio's Pizzeria
Sidney, A Short Drive South Of Anna • Sit-Down Pizzeria With A Full Italian Menu • Best For Lingering Over Dinner
A family-friendly Sidney staple that pairs well-made pies with a relaxed, old-school dining room.
Amelio's is the kind of place where teams and families pile into booths after games, splitting pizzas and baskets of garlic bread. Their crust lands between thin and thick, with plenty of cheese and generous toppings, plus a solid lineup of pastas and subs if not everyone at the table wants pizza. It’s an easy choice when you want a proper meal out rather than just a quick carryout run.
03
Heaviest hitters
Fat Jack's Pizza
Wapakoneta, North Of Anna • Hearty Midwestern Pizza Shop • Best For Big, Loaded Pies
Known for thick layers of toppings and cheese, Fat Jack's is built for serious appetites.
Fat Jack's in Wapakoneta is a regional favorite when you want a pizza that really eats like a meal. The crust is sturdy enough to hold piles of pepperoni, sausage, and veggies, and the portions are generous even by small-town Ohio standards. It’s a smart move for feeding a crowd back in Anna, especially if you call ahead and time your pickup with a Wapak errand run.
04
Best for groups
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill
St. Marys, Northwest Of Anna • Lively Pizza-And-Grill Family Restaurant • Group-Friendly Choice With Something For Everyone
A big, buzzy spot where you can get specialty pizzas alongside burgers, wings, and a cold beer.
Beer Barrel in St. Marys feels more like a full-on outing than a quick pizza stop, which makes it great for birthdays, team dinners, or meeting friends halfway. The menu runs from classic pepperoni to loaded specialty pies, with plenty of non-pizza options for picky eaters. With TVs, roomy tables, and a casual bar atmosphere, it’s worth the extra miles when you want pizza plus a night out.
05
Most reliable chain
Donatos Pizza
Sidney, Along The Main Retail Corridor • Chain Spot Known For Edge-To-Edge Toppings • Reliable Carryout And Delivery Choice
A dependable option for crisp, square-cut pizzas packed with toppings and easy online ordering.
The Sidney Donatos is a practical pick when you want predictable quality and fast service without driving into a big city. Their trademark thin crust and edge-to-edge pepperoni make it especially good for feeding a mix of kids and adults who all like something slightly different. With online ordering and delivery coverage into nearby areas, it’s often the most convenient way to get a solid pizza night going in or near Anna.