01
Best overall pick
Papa Oley's Pizzaria
Downtown Antwerp • Old-School Pan Pizza Shop • Classic Hometown Favorite
Thick, cheesy pies and a warm small-town dining room make Papa Oley’s the default pizza night choice in Antwerp.
Locals swear by the buttery, edge-to-edge cheese and generous toppings on Papa Oley’s signature pan pizzas. The atmosphere is exactly what you want from a village pizzeria: friendly staff, families at big tables, and plenty of leftovers to take home. It’s the place you send visitors when you want them to understand why people love living here.
02
Top Antwerp delivery
Puckerbrush Pizza (Antwerp)
South Side Antwerp • Small-Town Slice And Subs Counter • Best For Big Carryout Orders
Puckerbrush’s Antwerp location keeps things simple with hearty pies, cheesy bread, and subs that travel well.
This spot leans into classic comfort: sturdy crusts, plenty of cheese, and toppings that don’t skimp. It’s especially popular for carryout on busy weeknights and after local games, when families call in big orders of pizza, wings, and garlic bread. Expect straightforward, satisfying pizza rather than fussy gourmet combinations.
03
Best short-drive classic
Puckerbrush Pizza (Payne)
Main Street Payne • Family-Run Takeout Pizzeria • Worth-The-Drive Specialty Pies
The original Puckerbrush in Payne draws Antwerp folks with its crisp-edged pies and small-town charm.
Just a quick drive from Antwerp, the Payne shop feels like the kind of place that has known its customers for generations. The crust lands in that sweet spot between soft and crispy, with plenty of options for loaded specialty pizzas. Pair a couple of large pies with their cheesy sides and you’ve got an easy way to feed a crowd after a day on the road or in the fields.
04
Best for game night
MyWay Pizzeria & Bar
Downtown Paulding • Casual Pizzeria And Bar • Best For Pizza And A Pint
MyWay in Paulding mixes well-made pies with a laid-back bar atmosphere that’s ideal for watching the game.
If you don’t mind a short drive, MyWay gives you something you won’t find in every village: a full bar to go with your pizza. The menu leans toward classic toppings and shareable appetizers, so it’s easy to settle in with friends for a few hours. It’s a solid choice when you want pizza night to feel more like a night out than a quick carryout run.
05
Best for customization
Marco's Pizza
East Side Defiance • Fast-Delivery Chain Pizzeria • Reliable Chain With Lots Of Options
Marco’s in Defiance is the go-to chain stop when you want plenty of crust styles, sauces, and toppings to mix and match.
While it’s a bit farther from Antwerp than the strictly local spots, this location earns its place on the list for consistency and variety. You can build your own pie with different crusts, sauces, and toppings, or grab one of their loaded specialty combinations if you don’t feel like deciding. It’s especially handy for larger groups where everyone wants something a little different.