01
Best overall pick
Gionino's Pizzeria
Near Kidron • Neighborhood Carryout And Delivery • Local Favorite For Takeout
Reliable, generously topped pies and fried chicken just a short drive from the center of Apple Creek.
This Gionino's location on Kidron Road is the go-to for many Apple Creek families when nobody feels like cooking. The crust is sturdy enough to handle their classic, edge-to-edge toppings, and the sweet-leaning sauce is very Ohio in all the right ways. Round out a big order with JoJo potatoes and fried chicken, and you’re set for a casual night in or a post-game team feast.
02
Classic local icon
Coccia House
Downtown Wooster • Old-School Italian Pizzeria • Iconic Sit-Down Choice
A beloved Wooster institution serving hefty, cheese-forward pies that are worth the drive from Apple Creek.
Coccia House has been a pizza pilgrimage spot for Wayne County locals for decades, and it still feels like a time capsule in the best way. Expect thick, bready crusts, piles of cheese, and toppings that go right to the edge on big, shareable pizzas. Plan on a relaxed, sit-down meal here—this is the place to linger over a pitcher of soda or beer and a couple of giant pies with friends or family.
03
Worth the drive
Park Street Pizza
Sugarcreek Village Center • Modern Craft-Pizza Spot • Destination For Food-Loving Day-Trippers
Thoughtfully sourced ingredients, creative toppings, and a lively small-town setting make this a standout road-trip pizza stop.
Park Street Pizza takes a more modern, ingredient-driven approach, using locally sourced meats and produce whenever possible. Their crust strikes a nice balance—chewy with a bit of char—and the menu ranges from classic pepperoni to inventive specialty pies, plus vegetarian-friendly options. Pair a pizza with their house-made sauces and a salad, and make an afternoon of exploring Sugarcreek before heading back toward Apple Creek.
04
Best for big groups
East of Chicago Pizza
Dalton Strip • Casual Buffet And Carryout Pizzeria • Best For Big Groups And Teams
Flexible buffet-style and build-your-own options that work well for teams, youth groups, and hungry families.
The Dalton East of Chicago location is popular with local teams and church groups thanks to its buffet-style setup and crowd-pleasing menu. The signature thick, pan-style crust and loaded toppings are classic Ohio comfort food, and the salad bar and dessert pizzas keep picky eaters happy. It’s an easy choice when you need to feed a lot of people without overthinking it and don’t mind a short drive from Apple Creek.
05
Chain with local following
Donatos Pizza
North Wooster • Fast-Casual Ohio Chain • Reliable Game-Night Standby
Crisp, edge-to-edge topping pizzas from a familiar Ohio chain with efficient carryout and delivery.
Donatos in Wooster is a practical pick when you want something consistent and quick on the way back to Apple Creek. Their hallmark is a thin, crispy crust absolutely covered in finely chopped toppings, so every slice feels loaded. Online ordering and predictable timing make it especially handy for weeknight dinners and last-minute game-night spreads.