01
Best overall pick
Kelly's Pizza
Near Apple Valley Lake In Howard • Classic Small-Town Pizzeria • Local Favorite
The go-to pizza shop for Apple Valley and Howard, known for its crust and hearty toppings.
Kelly’s is the spot locals name first when you ask where to get pizza around Apple Valley. The crust has a satisfying, Goldilocks thickness and a light chew, with a sauce that’s just sweet enough to stand out. It’s a relaxed, no-frills operation that focuses on generous toppings, friendly service, and takeout that holds up well for the short drive back to the lake.
02
Best for game night
The Pub
Howard Village Center • Casual Pub With Pizza • Best For Pizza And A Pint
A lively Howard hangout where you can pair specialty pizzas with cold beer and a game on TV.
The Pub is a solid choice when you want more atmosphere than a basic carryout counter. Their pizzas lean toward the hearty side, with plenty of cheese and a good mix of classic and creative toppings that play well with wings and burgers on the same table. It’s especially popular on weekends and game days, when the bar energy and big pies make it easy to linger with friends.
03
Best value pies
Creno's Pizza
North Mount Vernon On Coshocton Avenue • Carryout And Delivery Pizzeria • Best For Big, Shareable Pizzas
An Ohio-based chain known for oversized pies, plenty of toppings, and budget-friendly deals.
Creno’s in Mount Vernon is worth the short drive if you’re feeding a cabin full of friends or a hungry family. The pizzas are large, cut into party-style squares, and loaded edge-to-edge, making it easy to stretch a couple of boxes into a full meal. Many Apple Valley regulars plan ahead, swinging by Creno’s on their way back from town errands to bring home hot, crowd-pleasing pizza.
04
Best for crispy thin crust
Donatos Pizza
East Mount Vernon Shopping Corridor • Thin-Crust Chain Pizzeria • Best For Consistent Thin-Crust
A Columbus-born chain offering ultra-thin, crispy crust pizza with edge-to-edge toppings.
Donatos is a favorite for those who like their pizza on the lighter, crisper side. The crust bakes up thin and crackly, and the signature edge-to-edge topping style means every square-cut slice has a full mix of cheese and toppings. It’s a convenient stop when you’re already in Mount Vernon and want a predictable, quick meal to bring back toward Apple Valley.
05
Best late-night option
Domino's Pizza
South Mount Vernon • Delivery-Focused Chain Pizzeria • Late-Night Pick
A reliable choice for fast delivery, customizable pizzas, and sides when cravings hit after dark.
For nights when you’d rather not leave the house or cabin, Domino’s in Mount Vernon is the most practical option. The menu is broad, with everything from build-your-own pizzas to stuffed cheesy bread and wings, so it’s easy to keep a mixed group happy. Delivery coverage into the Apple Valley area may vary, but even a quick pickup run can be faster than waiting for a table elsewhere.