01
Best overall pick
Doughtroit
East Findlay Along Tiffin Avenue • Modern Craft Pizza Shop • Destination For Pizza Fans
Creative, chewy-crust pies and thoughtful toppings make Doughtroit a standout worth the short drive from Arcadia.
Doughtroit leans into inventive combinations on a sturdy, flavorful crust, so it feels more like a modern pizzeria than a basic delivery joint. Expect things like loaded specialty pies, quality cheese, and well-balanced sauces rather than just generic toppings. It is an easy go-to when you want something a bit more special without heading to a big city.
02
Best for carryout and delivery
Heavenly Pizza
North Findlay On North Main Street • Family-Run Carryout And Delivery Shop • Beloved Local Staple
Heavenly Pizza is the kind of long-running local shop people grow up with and keep coming back to for familiar, saucy pies.
Known for its fresh dough and generous toppings, Heavenly leans classic rather than trendy, with pizzas, subs, and wings that travel well. It is especially handy if you are heading back toward Arcadia and want something hot to bring home. Portions are solid, and the menu is broad enough to keep picky eaters happy.
03
Best for groups
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill
East Findlay By The Shopping Corridor • Lively Sports Bar And Grill • Best For Groups And Game Days
Beer Barrel pairs crowd-pleasing pizzas with a full menu and plenty of TVs, making it ideal when you want more than just a quick slice.
This is the spot to meet friends or bring a bigger family when some want pizza and others are thinking burgers, wings, or salads. The crust is on the heartier side, built to handle heavy toppings and shareable specialty combinations. It is also one of the easier places to keep everyone entertained during a long meal, especially on game nights.
04
Best classic takeout
Jac & Do's Pizza
Southwest Findlay Neighborhood Strip • Classic Ohio-Style Pizza Joint • Budget-Friendly Favorite
Jac & Do's serves straightforward, thin-crust Ohio pizza with a loyal following and prices that make feeding a crowd easier.
This is a no-frills operation in the best way: crispy-edged pies, lots of pepperoni, and a sauce that tastes like small-town pizza should. Locals lean on it for youth sports parties, casual Friday nights, and quick carryout runs. If you want that nostalgic, slightly greasy box of pizza without spending much, this is the move.
05
Best downtown stop
Joey Fratello's Pizzeria
Downtown Findlay • New York-Style Slice Shop And Pizzeria • Best For A Quick Downtown Bite
Joey Fratello's brings foldable slices and whole pies to downtown Findlay, perfect when you are mixing pizza with a walk through town.
Expect thinner, larger slices with a bit of chew, closer to big-city street pizza than typical Midwest pan pie. It is an easy stop before or after events in downtown Findlay, with enough seating for a casual meal but a setup that works just as well for grab-and-go. The simple menu keeps the focus on well-executed classics like pepperoni, sausage, and white pies.