01
Best small-town classic
Petey's Pizza
Just South Of Arcanum On State Route 127 • Small-Town Carryout Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A no-frills spot serving crowd-pleasing pies that feel tailor-made for takeout nights and ball games.
Petey’s leans into everything people love about a country-road pizza joint: generous toppings, friendly service, and consistent pies. The crust lands in that sweet spot between chewy and crispy, making it easy to please a mixed group. Call ahead on busy evenings; locals know this is one of the area’s most reliable takeout options.
02
Best overall pick
Picnic's Pizza & Grille
Downtown Arcanum • Family Grill And Pizza Shop • Best For Families
A friendly sit-down spot where you can pair well-built pizzas with burgers, subs, and a relaxed small-town vibe.
Picnic’s is the go-to choice when you want pizza but not everyone at the table is in the mood for the same thing. Their pizzas are hearty, with plenty of topping combinations, and the broader menu makes it easy to keep kids and non-pizza fans happy. Weekday hours and a casual dining room make it a natural fit for after-practice dinners and low-key meetups in town.
03
Best for customizable pies
Marco's Pizza
Greenville – Wagner Avenue Corridor • Takeout-Focused Chain Pizzeria • Best For Custom Toppings
A reliable spot for highly customizable pizzas, easy online ordering, and quick pickup or delivery from nearby Greenville.
Marco’s gives Arcanum-area diners chain-level convenience without skimping on options, from specialty pies to build-your-own combinations. The crust and sauce are consistent, and the online ordering system makes large orders for parties or work events straightforward. It’s particularly handy when you’re in a hurry or feeding a crowd with different topping preferences.
04
Best for Dayton-style tradition
Cassano's Pizza King
Downtown Greenville • Classic Ohio/Dayton-Style Pizzeria • Best For Thin-Crust Fans
A regional favorite known for its cracker-thin crust, edge-to-edge toppings, and nostalgic feel.
Cassano’s brings the classic Dayton-area pizza style to Greenville, making it worth the short drive from Arcanum for anyone who loves ultra-thin, crispy crusts. Pizzas come cut into small squares, with toppings spread all the way to the edge for maximum flavor in every bite. It’s a great choice when you’re craving something a bit different from standard chain pies, especially for dine-in or relaxed takeout nights.
05
Best familiar standby
Pizza Hut
Greenville – North Side • Family-Friendly Dine-In And Carryout Chain • Best Value Lunch Stop
A dependable option for pan pizzas, stuffed crusts, and combos that work well for quick lunches or budget-conscious family meals.
Greenville’s Pizza Hut offers all the classics—pan, hand-tossed, and stuffed-crust pies—plus wings and sides that make ordering for a group simple. It’s a good pick when you want something familiar, with frequent deals that help keep costs in check. For Arcanum locals running errands in Greenville, it’s an easy add-on stop for takeout on the way home.