Arlington may be a small village, but it sits within easy reach of some very good pizza. Most locals look to nearby Findlay and Bluffton for everything from classic Ohio-style pies to sports-bar slices and family carryout. These five spots are reliable picks for a casual night out, a quick pickup on the way home, or a low-key weekend drive for great pizza.
A longtime Findlay staple known for generously topped pies and friendly counter service.
Heavenly Pizza is the place many Arlington-area families think of first when someone suggests pizza night. The crust is soft with a light crunch at the edge, and toppings are piled higher than most chains. It’s primarily a takeout and delivery operation, making it an easy stop when you’re heading back into town on US-68.
Old-school, square-cut pizza with a cozy dine-in feel that works well for kids and groups.
Jac & Do's serves the kind of thin, square-cut pizza many northwest Ohioans grew up on. The sauce leans savory, the cheese browns nicely, and the menu has enough appetizers and sandwiches to keep everyone at the table happy. It’s a comfortable, no-frills option when you want to sit down and linger over a couple of large pies.
A spacious spot pairing thick, hearty pizzas with a full bar and plenty of TVs.
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill is where you go when the whole crew wants pizza plus burgers, wings, and a decent beer list. The pizzas are substantial, with a thicker crust and lots of specialty combinations that arrive on raised stands to share around the table. With roomy booths and wall-to-wall screens, it’s ideal for watching the game after a short drive up from Arlington.
Reliable, customizable pies with multiple crust styles and easy ordering for takeout or delivery.
East of Chicago in Findlay is a practical go-to when convenience matters as much as the pizza itself. You can choose from thin, pan, or deep-dish crusts, plus build-your-own or pick from a long list of specialty pies. Portions are generous, deals are frequent, and the location makes it a straightforward option for Arlington residents who want dinner brought to the door.
A Bluffton favorite offering crisp-edged pies and a relaxed small-town atmosphere.
Padrone's Pizza in Bluffton is a nice excuse for a short drive east of Arlington, especially if you enjoy a crisp, slightly chewy crust. The toppings are well-balanced rather than overloaded, so the crust and sauce still stand out. Grab a booth downtown, or call ahead and take your order back home for a change of pace from the Findlay options.