01
Classic Cincinnati standby
LaRosa's Pizzeria – St. Bernard
St. Bernard • Cincinnati-Style Family Pizzeria • Local Icon
A go-to for Cincinnati-style pies, piled-high hoagies, and crowd-pleasing pasta just south of Arlington Heights.
If you grew up anywhere near Cincinnati, LaRosa’s is probably your default pizza night choice, and the St. Bernard location is one of the most convenient for Arlington Heights. Expect cracker-thin crust, sweet-leaning sauce, and edge-to-edge toppings in classic hometown fashion. It’s reliable for big family orders, sports-watching spreads, and those nights when you just want the familiar taste of “LaRosa’s on the way.”
02
Best for families
Dewey's Pizza – Kenwood
Near Kenwood Towne Centre • Creative, Sit-Down Pizzeria • Family-Friendly Favorite
Hand-tossed, generously topped pies and a lively dining room make this a popular choice before or after Kenwood errands.
Dewey’s in Kenwood offers a more polished take on pizza night without feeling stuffy or fussy. The menu leans into specialties like the Southwest BBQ Chicken and the Green Lantern, plus seasonal pies that keep regulars interested. Big windows, an open kitchen, and plenty of booths make it easy to bring kids, split a salad and a large pizza, and be back to Arlington Heights in time for an early bedtime.
03
Best beer-and-pizza combo
Taft's Brewpourium – Spring Grove Village
Spring Grove Village • Brewery Taproom With New Haven–Inspired Pizza • Craft Beer And Pizza Destination
A spacious taproom pouring house-made beers alongside chewy, char-spotted pizzas baked on a coal-fired-style crust.
Just a short hop down I‑75, Taft’s Brewpourium pairs house brews with a menu centered on New Haven–style pies—thin, chewy, and blistered in all the right spots. Toppings range from classic pepperoni to more adventurous combinations that play well with their IPAs and lagers. The warehouse-style space, long communal tables, and easy parking make it an excellent choice for group meetups or casual weekends out of the village.
04
Best wood-fired option
Catch-a-Fire Pizza – Blue Ash
Blue Ash • Wood-Fired Pizza And Burger Spot • Worth The Short Drive
Artful wood-fired pizzas with a hint of char and creative toppings make this Blue Ash spot a destination from Arlington Heights.
Catch-a-Fire in Blue Ash feels like a modern neighborhood hangout, with a big focus on the oven at the heart of the kitchen. The crust comes out light but structured, with just enough smoke to support everything from simple Margheritas to pies loaded with house-smoked meats. It’s a good bet when you want something a little more chef-driven than delivery but still relaxed enough for jeans and a hoodie.
05
Best for big slices
Goodfellas Pizzeria – Over-the-Rhine
Over-The-Rhine • New York–Style Slice Shop • Late-Night Favorite
Oversized New York–style slices and whole pies draw downtown crowds, especially after a game or concert.
When a standard large pizza won’t cut it, Goodfellas in OTR delivers foldable, New York–style slices that hang over the plate. The shop has a casual, urban feel, and you can grab a slice at the counter or take a full pie home after an evening downtown. It’s a little farther from Arlington Heights than the neighborhood joints, but the combination of size, flavor, and late hours makes it a solid option when you’re already heading into the city.