01
Best overall pick
Holy Pepperoni Ashland
Cleveland Avenue North Of Downtown • New Haven–Style Apizza Shop • Destination For Pizza Purists
Charred, thin, and chewy pies make this the place locals mention when they talk about serious pizza in Ashland.
Holy Pepperoni brings a New Haven–inspired take to town, with thin crusts that come out of the oven blistered and a little smoky. Toppings lean classic but careful—think tangy red sauce, garlic, and plenty of pepperoni with a noticeable curl and crisp. It’s a strong pick when you want something a bit more crafted than standard delivery but still casual enough for a weeknight dinner.
02
Classic Ashland institution
DorLo Pizza
Orange Road Corridor • Old-School Local Pizzeria • Best For Classic Ashland Flavor
A fixture for decades, DorLo delivers the kind of square-cut, cheesy pies many locals grew up on.
DorLo leans into nostalgia with its slightly thick, bready crust, generous cheese, and edge-to-edge toppings. It’s the place people order from when relatives come back to town and want the pizza they remember. Go for a pepperoni or sausage pie, add a side of their classic breadsticks, and expect a straightforward, comforting hometown style.
03
Family-friendly favorite
Donna D’s Family Pizza
Us-250 East Of Town • Family Pizza And Pasta Shop • Best For Family Dinners
A long-running, family-oriented spot known for well-loaded pies and a small-town, everyone-knows-you feel.
Donna D’s has been feeding Ashland families for generations, with a menu built around hearty, crowd-pleasing pizzas. Crusts are on the thicker side, with a soft interior and enough structure to hold lots of toppings, making it ideal for deluxe and meat-lovers combinations. It’s a natural choice for birthday gatherings, post-game meals, or any night you’re ordering for a mixed group of kids and adults.
04
Best chain-style option
Gionino’s Pizzeria
Claremont Avenue Strip • Regional Carryout And Delivery Chain • Best For Big Groups And Game Nights
Known for reliably tasty pies and fried chicken, this spot shines when you’re feeding a crowd.
Gionino’s pairs classic Midwest-style pizza with its well-known fried chicken, which makes building a spread for game day or family get-togethers easy. The crust is medium thickness with a slightly chewy bite, and the toppings skew generous and salty in a way that works well with a pitcher of soda or beer at home. Order a couple of large pizzas, add chicken and jojos, and you’re set for a no-fuss crowd-pleaser.
05
Quick bite standout
Besta Fasta Pizza
Just South Of Downtown • Quick-Service Hometown Pizzeria • Best For A Fast, Affordable Bite
A straightforward, budget-friendly shop that focuses on hot, fresh pies without much fuss.
Besta Fasta leans into speed and value, making it an easy choice when you want pizza in the car on the way home or a simple dinner without a big bill. Expect classic toppings, a no-nonsense crust, and portions that feel generous for the price. It’s particularly handy for students, busy families, or anyone looking to grab a pizza without planning ahead.