01
Best all-around pick
Gibeyes Pizza & Pub
Downtown Ashley • Lively Small-Town Pub And Pizzeria • Best All-Around Pick
A true small-town hub where you can grab a solid pie, a drink, and catch up with half the village.
Sitting just off High Street, Gibeyes feels like the classic local place everyone seems to know. The menu leans into generously topped pizzas and familiar pub favorites, so it works just as well for a family dinner as it does for a casual night out. It’s the first name locals tend to mention when someone asks where to get pizza in Ashley proper.
02
Takeout staple
Long Branch Pizza
Residential Ashley • Classic Carryout Pizza Shop • Go-To For Takeout Night
Straightforward, well-made pizzas that are easy to grab on your way home after a busy day.
Long Branch is the kind of spot you rely on for an easy, no-drama pizza night. The crust runs on the classic Ohio side of things—sturdy enough for plenty of toppings without getting soggy. Call ahead, swing by to pick it up, and you’ve got a dependable option that keeps regulars coming back week after week.
03
Pub-style pies
Rusted Nail Grill & Tavern
East High Street, Ashley • Laid-Back Grill And Tavern With Pizza • Best For Pizza And A Beer
A relaxed tavern where hearty pizzas share the spotlight with burgers, wings, and a cold drink list.
On the east end of High Street, Rusted Nail combines a neighborhood-bar atmosphere with a surprisingly solid pizza lineup. The pies lean hearty—think lots of cheese, plenty of toppings, and crust that stands up to it all. It’s an easy pick when a group wants something more than just pizza, but still expects that pizza to hold its own.
04
College-town favorite
Mohio Pizza
Downtown Delaware • Modern College-Town Pizzeria • Best Quick Stop Before Or After A Game
Casual slices and pies near the heart of Delaware’s college scene, ideal for quick, satisfying fuel.
About 15 minutes south of Ashley, Mohio Pizza draws both students and locals with its quick service and generous slices. The vibe is unfussy and energetic, with plenty of topping options and combos that appeal to a crowd. It’s a reliable stop before a game, a show, or when you’re already in Delaware and want something fast but better than chain pizza.
05
Wood-fired standout
Amato’s Woodfired Pizza
Historic Downtown Delaware • Wood-Fired Italian-Style Pizzeria • Best For Date Night
Neapolitan-style pies fired in a hot oven, with a cozy downtown setting that feels a notch more special.
If you’re willing to make the short drive into Delaware, Amato’s is where you go when you want pizza to feel like an occasion. The wood-fired crust comes out blistered and chewy, topped with thoughtfully chosen ingredients rather than just piled high. Pair a pie with a salad and something from the drink list, and it turns into an easy, low-key date night or relaxed evening with friends.