01
Best overall pick
Blades Pizza
Central Ashville On Long Street • Casual, Family-Friendly Pizzeria With Wings And Subs • Local Favorite
Hand-tossed pies, generous toppings, and a laid-back dining room make Blades the go-to pizza stop in Ashville.
If you ask around town where to get pizza, Blades is the name you’ll hear most. The crust hits that sweet spot between chewy and crisp, and they don’t skimp on cheese or toppings. It’s an easy choice for families or anyone who wants classic small-town Ohio pizzeria vibes without overthinking it.
02
Best for big appetites
Triple Play Pizza
Cromley Street In The Heart Of Ashville • Neighborhood Pizza Shop With Wings, Subs, Salads, And Ice Cream • Best For Families And Teams
Triple Play leans into variety, pairing hearty pizzas with wings, subs, and ice cream that work perfectly for hungry groups.
This is the spot to bring the whole crew after a game or a long day at the park. Pizzas come loaded, there are plenty of sides to pass around, and the ice cream gives kids (and adults) something to look forward to after the last slice. Call-ahead orders and straightforward pricing make it especially handy for feeding a crowd.
03
Best seasonal stop
Baseball's Dairy Diamond
Near The Ballfields On The Edge Of Ashville • Retro, Baseball-Themed Stand With Pizza And Ice Cream • Best For Casual Summer Slices
Part ice cream stand, part pizza stop, Baseball's Dairy Diamond is a fun warm-weather choice when you want a quick pie by the ballfields.
This place feels like classic small-town summer: kids in uniforms, families at picnic tables, and the smell of pizza drifting over the diamond. The menu is straightforward but satisfying, with simple pies that hit the spot when you’re more focused on the game than gourmet toppings. It’s especially good for a low-key, eat-outside kind of evening.
04
Best for dinner and drinks
Jackie Ray's Grill & Pub
Historic Cromley Street In Ashville • Sit-Down Grill And Pub With A Strong Pizza Lineup • Best For A Night Out
Known for hearty pub fare and a surprisingly good pizza menu, Jackie Ray's is where you go when you want a slice with a pint.
Housed in a distinctive historic building, Jackie Ray’s offers a different vibe than the typical pizza counter. The pies come with well-charred crusts and thoughtful topping combos, making them easy to share alongside burgers, wings, and appetizers. It’s a solid pick when you want pizza but also a sit-down atmosphere with cocktails or a cold beer.
05
Worth-the-drive pick
Pizza Cottage (Circleville)
Circleville, A Short Drive South Of Ashville • Lively Regional Pizza Restaurant With Full Menu And Bar • Best For Broader Menu Options
A regional favorite, Pizza Cottage in Circleville serves crispy-edged pizzas, pastas, and appetizers in a busy, family-friendly setting.
When you’re willing to hop in the car for more options, locals often point to Pizza Cottage in Circleville. The crust has a nice crunch, and you can build your own or choose from a long list of specialty pies, plus salads, pasta, and shareable starters. It’s an easy choice for mixed groups where not everyone is in a strict pizza-only mood.