01
Best overall pick
Backyard Pizza and Raw Bar
Downtown Huntington, Wv • Wood-Fired Artisan Pizzeria And Raw Bar • Destination For Creative Pies And Craft Drinks
Inventive wood-fired pies and a lively downtown bar scene make this spot worth the river crossing.
Backyard Pizza builds char-speckled, wood-fired pies topped with everything from classic pepperoni to seasonal veggies and house-made sausage. The bar program is strong too, with craft beers and cocktails that make it easy to linger after dinner. It is an easy drive from Athalia into downtown Huntington, especially if you're already headed over for a night out.
02
Coziest atmosphere
Lola's Pizza
Southside Huntington, Wv • Charming Cottage-Style Pizza Cafe • Cozy Date-Night Choice
A tucked-away cottage turning out thin, bubbly-crusted pizzas with big flavor and a relaxed vibe.
Lola's feels more like a friend’s house than a restaurant, with its cottage setting, warm lighting, and laid-back patio out back. The menu leans toward creative, with combinations like goat cheese and roasted vegetables alongside more traditional toppings, all on a light, crisp crust. It is a great pick when you want a slower, sit-down meal rather than a quick slice.
03
Great for sharing
Husson's Pizza
West Huntington, Wv • Old-School Local Pizza Chain • Best For Big, Shareable Pies
Big, topping-loaded pizzas and a classic hometown feel make Husson's a go-to for groups.
Husson's is the place to go when you need to feed a crowd without overthinking it. Their large and party-sized pizzas come piled with toppings, and the crust hits that sweet spot between airy and chewy. Add in sides like cheesy bread, wings, and salads, and you have an easy, family-friendly option after games or long days on the river.
04
Closest regional chain
Gino's Pizza & Spaghetti House
Proctorville, Oh Along Oh-7 • Carryout And Delivery Pizza Shop • Convenient Stop Close To Athalia
A regional staple just up the highway, serving hearty pizzas, subs, and pasta for easy pickup on the way home.
For Athalia residents, the Proctorville Gino's is one of the closest reliable options when a pizza craving hits. Expect generous cheese, a slightly thicker crust, and well-loaded specialty pies, plus spaghetti dinners and hot subs if not everyone at home is in a pizza mood. It works especially well for call-ahead carryout on busy weeknights.
05
Best for families
Giovanni's Pizza
Chesapeake, Oh Riverfront • Neighborhood Pizza And Pasta Joint • Family-Friendly Choice
Crisp-edged pies, stromboli, and hearty Italian-American plates make this an easy crowd-pleaser.
Giovanni's in Chesapeake is a comfortable, no-frills spot where the focus is on filling, familiar food. The pizzas are known for their well-browned crusts and balanced sauce, and there are plenty of baked pastas and sandwiches to round out a meal. It is a practical option for families meeting up from both sides of the river, with something on the menu for everyone.