01
Best overall pick
Kinsey's Korner Restaurant
Atwater • Small-Town Family Restaurant With Pizza And Italian Classics • Best Sit-Down Option In Atwater
Homestyle mains, hearty pizzas, and friendly service make Kinsey's Korner an easy choice when you want to stay right in Atwater.
Kinsey's Korner has the cozy, everyone-knows-your-name feel you want from a small-town spot, and their pizzas are better than you might expect from a general family restaurant. The crust is sturdy enough to handle plenty of toppings, with a sauce that leans comforting rather than flashy. It’s a convenient pick for families or mixed groups, since you can pair a pizza with pastas, sandwiches, and classic diner-style dinners at the same table.
02
Worth-the-drive takeout
Gionino's Pizzeria
Rootstown • Takeout-Focused Ohio-Style Pizzeria • Neighborhood Takeout Favorite
Gionino's in Rootstown turns out thick, cheesy pies with that classic Northeast Ohio flavor profile.
If you’re craving that loaded, slightly indulgent Ohio-style pizza, Rootstown’s Gionino's is a solid bet. Expect a golden, chewy crust, plenty of cheese, and toppings that go all the way to the edge, plus their well-known fried chicken and JoJo potatoes if you want to make it a full spread. It’s primarily a call-ahead or online-order spot, ideal for picking up on your way back along I-76 or when you need to feed a crowd without fuss.
03
Stark County classic
Pizza Oven
Alliance • Old-School Local Pizza Chain • Classic Stark County-Style Pizza
Alliance’s Pizza Oven outpost delivers the sweet-sauce, edge-to-edge toppings style locals crave.
Pizza Oven is a mini-institution in this part of Ohio, and the Alliance location saves Atwater folks a longer drive into Canton. The pies lean toward a slightly sweet red sauce with generous pepperoni and a square-cut, party-style presentation that works well for game nights and family gatherings. Expect a carryout-first setup with straightforward service and pizza that tastes like childhood for many Stark County natives.
04
Most reliable delivery
Domino's Pizza
Alliance • National Delivery Chain • Fast, Late-Night-Friendly Delivery
When you want predictable pizza fast, the Alliance Domino's is the workhorse of the area.
For those nights when convenience matters more than hunting down a hidden gem, the Alliance Domino's covers the basics well. Online ordering and tracking make it easy to customize crusts, sauces, and toppings, and you can round out an order with wings, pastas, and sandwiches. It’s a practical pick for larger groups or late evenings when independent spots are closed but the pizza craving still hits.
05
Great for groups
Guido's Pizza and Catering
Hartville • Family-Run Pizzeria And Italian Spot • Best For Big, Shareable Pies
Guido's in Hartville bakes hefty, crowd-pleasing pizzas that hold up to a drive back to Atwater.
Located just south in Hartville, Guido's is popular for its substantial pies and homey Italian comfort food. The crust has enough heft to support plenty of toppings, and specialty combinations—along with pasta and subs—make it easy to please a whole group. It’s a smart stop if you’re already in Hartville for the marketplace or lake and want to bring a hot, shareable dinner back home; calling ahead on busy weekends is wise.