01
Best overall pick
Angelo's
Central Aurora • Classic Family Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A cozy, no-fuss parlor where locals head first when they’re craving a classic pie and a low-key night out.
Angelo’s feels like the kind of place that’s been in the family rotation for years: straightforward menu, friendly staff, and pizza that hits the spot without trying too hard. The crust lands in that sweet spot between soft and crisp, with well-seasoned sauce and generous cheese. It’s an easy choice for dine-in or takeout when you want a classic Aurora pizza experience.
02
Best for variety
Teresa's Pizza
North Aurora Road Corridor • Neighborhood Pizza And Pasta Shop • Great For Groups
Teresa’s pairs crowd-pleasing pies with pasta, wings, and subs, making it a reliable one-stop order for hungry families or gatherings.
Known for its square-cut pies and hearty toppings, Teresa’s is especially handy when you’re feeding a mix of tastes. The menu stretches well beyond pizza, so you can round out an order with baked pasta, wings, and garlic bread without hopping between places. It’s a go-to for casual weekend dinners, game nights, and any time you need a tableful of food with minimal fuss.
03
Best neighborhood feel
Uncle Spike's Pizzeria
East Garfield Road • Casual Neighborhood Spot • Best For Takeout Night
A small, friendly shop turning out thoughtfully made pies that feel a notch more personal than the big chains.
Uncle Spike’s leans into straightforward recipes done well, with balanced sauce, good cheese coverage, and a crust that holds up on the drive home. The shop has a local-first feel, and staff are happy to talk through toppings if you like to customize. It’s an ideal choice for an easy pick-up dinner when you still want something that tastes made just for you.
04
Best pizza-and-chicken combo
Gionino's Pizzeria
South Aurora Road • Carryout-Focused Pizzeria • Great For Sharing
Gionino’s is the place to go when your crew wants both pizza and crispy fried chicken from a single order.
The pies here lean hearty, with a slightly thicker crust and plenty of cheese, making them ideal for splitting among a hungry crowd. Their JoJo-style potatoes and fried chicken are local favorites, turning a simple pizza run into a full comfort-food spread. It’s especially handy for parties, movie nights, or any gathering where you want a little of everything on the table.
05
Most reliable chain option
Pizza Hut
Barrington Town Square • National Chain Pizzeria • Best For Late Hours And Deals
This Aurora Pizza Hut delivers the familiar pan pizza, wings, and deals that are hard to beat when convenience is the priority.
Set in Barrington Town Square, the location is easy to reach and keeps relatively long hours, which helps when dinner plans run late. You’ll find the full range of crust styles, wings, and sides, plus app-based specials that make feeding a group affordable. It’s the dependable choice when you want exactly what you expect from a big-name pizza chain.