01
Best overall pick
Capps Pizza – Austinburg
Austinburg Center • Classic Small-Town Pizzeria • Local Favorite For Dine-In Or Takeout
The Austinburg Capps is the go-to neighborhood hub for generous, cheesy pies and hearty sides.
This location is the most convenient stop for anyone staying in or passing directly through Austinburg. The menu leans into Midwestern comfort: thick layers of cheese, plenty of toppings, and familiar sides like wings and subs. It’s an easy choice for feeding a crowd after a game or a day on the road.
02
Best for a laid-back night out
Capps Pizza & Tavern – Leroy
Leroy Township, West Of Austinburg • Tavern-Style Pizzeria And Bar • Best For Pizza With A Pint
Capps’ Leroy outpost adds a full tavern vibe to the same reliable pizza locals know.
If you don’t mind a short drive west, the Leroy shop combines Capps’ hearty pizzas with a casual bar atmosphere. It’s the spot to linger over a pie, catch a game on TV, and sample wings or appetizers alongside your favorite drink. Locals use it as a relaxed meet-up point that still feels very small-town Ohio.
03
Worth-the-drive carryout
Capps Pizza – Orwell
Orwell, Southeast Of Austinburg • Carryout-Focused Hometown Shop • Best For Road-Trip Pick-Up
The Orwell Capps is a solid stop when you’re already on the road and want familiar, filling pizza to go.
Heading through the southeast side of the county, Orwell’s Capps location is a smart detour for takeout. The pizzas are consistent with the rest of the mini-chain—plenty of cheese, classic toppings, and straightforward crust options. Pair a couple of large pies with salads or subs and you’re set for an easy night at a rental or back home.
04
Quickest delivery bet
Domino's Pizza – Ashtabula
Ashtabula – City Center • Chain Delivery Specialist • Best For Fast, Customizable Delivery
Domino’s in Ashtabula is the dependable choice when speed, deals, and online ordering matter most.
For many Austinburg-area households, Ashtabula’s Domino’s is the default option on busy weeknights. Online ordering and tracking make it easy to customize everything from thin-crust pies to specialty combinations, plus wings and sandwiches. It’s not a destination in itself, but it’s hard to argue with how quickly dinner shows up at the door.
05
Family-friendly chain classic
Pizza Hut – Ashtabula
Ashtabula – Retail Corridor • Sit-Down National Pizzeria • Best Sit-Down Chain Option For Families
Ashtabula’s Pizza Hut delivers the familiar pan pizzas and booths many families grew up with.
When you want something predictable with space for kids and groups, the Ashtabula Pizza Hut fits the bill. Expect the usual lineup of pan and hand-tossed pizzas, breadsticks, and shareable sides in a straightforward dining room. It’s a convenient stop to pair with shopping runs or errands in town before heading back toward Austinburg.