01
Classic Mahoning Valley pick
Wedgewood Pizza Austintown
Austintown - South Raccoon Road Corridor • Classic Youngstown-Style Pizzeria • Local Legend
Square-cut, cheese-forward pies that many locals point to as the benchmark for Youngstown-style pizza.
If you want to understand why Mahoning Valley pizza has a reputation, Wedgewood’s Austintown shop is a great starting point. Expect a slightly thicker crust, a generous layer of cheese, and toppings that run right to the edge of the pan. It’s mainly a takeout operation, so call ahead during peak hours if you don’t want to wait with the Friday-night crowd.
02
Best for big crowds
Westgate Pizza Company - Austintown
Austintown - Kirk Road Area • Old-School Neighborhood Pizza Shop • Best For Big Groups
Home of the oversized party pizza, ideal when you’re feeding a houseful during the game or a family get-together.
Westgate leans into the Mahoning Valley love of sheet pizza with huge pans that can handle a crowd. The crust is sturdy enough to carry heavy toppings, making it a smart move if you like your pizza loaded. It’s a straightforward, no-fuss shop where consistency and value matter more than frills.
03
Best sit-down option
Belleria Pizza & Italian Restaurant Austintown
Austintown - Mahoning Avenue Strip • Casual Italian Restaurant And Pizzeria • Best For Families
Family-friendly spot where you can pair a pan pizza with pasta, salads, and a lingering sit-down meal.
Belleria’s Austintown location works well when some people want pizza and others are thinking chicken parmesan or baked pasta. Their pizzas have a soft, substantial crust and plenty of sauce, with toppings that skew classic—pepperoni, sausage, peppers, and mushrooms. It’s a comfortable choice for dine-in with kids or relaxed weeknight dinners when you don’t feel like cooking.
04
Carryout staple nearby
Cocca's Pizza Mineral Ridge
Nearby Mineral Ridge • Takeout-Focused Pizzeria With Hearty Pies • Carryout Favorite
A short drive from Austintown, Cocca’s is known for thick, hearty pies, reliable delivery, and a long local following.
Cocca’s Mineral Ridge shop is close enough to be in the regular rotation for many Austintown households. Their pizza leans generous—plenty of cheese, a slightly chewy crust, and toppings that feel substantial rather than sparse. It’s a solid choice when you want a dependable carryout or delivery option that still feels distinctly local.
05
Best downtown detour
Avalon Downtown Pizzeria
Downtown Youngstown • Lively Downtown Bar And Pizzeria • Best For A Night Out
A short hop from Austintown, Avalon offers big-flavor pies in a livelier setting with drinks and a downtown vibe.
When you’re up for leaving the suburbs for an evening, Avalon Downtown gives you pizza alongside a bit of Youngstown nightlife. The menu leans creative, with specialty pies and toppings that go beyond the standard pepperoni-and-cheese routine. It’s a good pick if you want to pair pizza with a drink, watch a game, or make a casual night of it with friends.