01
Best overall pick
Besta Fasta Pizza
North Ashland • Classic Small-Town Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A longtime Ashland staple known for generous toppings and crowd-pleasing pies that travel well back to Bailey Lakes.
Besta Fasta is the kind of no-nonsense pizza place locals grow up with and never quite give up. The crust is sturdy, the cheese is plentiful, and the toppings lean classic—ideal if you’re feeding a mix of tastes. It’s a short drive from Bailey Lakes and especially handy for big orders on game nights or family gatherings.
02
Most family-friendly
Donna D's Family Pizza
East Ashland On Us 250 • Casual Family Pizza And Subs Shop • Best For Families
Comforting, no-frills pizza with a full lineup of subs, wings, and sides that make it easy to feed a group.
Donna D’s has the feel of a classic roadside pizza shop, conveniently set along US 250 for an easy swing-by on your way in or out of Bailey Lakes. The crust runs on the slightly thicker, softer side, with plenty of cheese and sauce that kids tend to latch onto. Add in their subs and wings and you’ve got a one-stop option for a relaxed family night at home.
03
Best for classic takeout
Dor-Lo Pizza
Central Ashland • Old-School Takeout Pizzeria • Go-To Carryout Spot
A retro-feeling shop turning out consistently solid pizzas that are easy to grab on the way back up to the lakes.
Dor-Lo leans into the old-school Ohio pizza playbook: straightforward crust, a slightly sweet sauce, and toppings stacked on thick. The operation is geared to carryout, so service is typically quick and efficient. It’s a reliable choice when you want hot pizza in the car and minimal fuss once you get back to Bailey Lakes.
04
Most distinctive pies
Holy Pepperoni Ashland
Cleveland Avenue, Ashland • New Haven–Style Apizza Shop • Best For Pizza Enthusiasts
A newer-school spot doing charred, chewy New Haven–style pies with more adventurous toppings than most local shops.
Holy Pepperoni stands out in Ashland for its thinner, slightly charred crust and more assertive flavor profiles. It’s the place to go if you care about details like dough texture and balanced toppings rather than just sheer volume. Expect a bit more of a destination feel—worth the extra few minutes from Bailey Lakes when you’re in the mood to linger over a well-made pie.
05
Best for wood-fired flavor
Ohio Fire
Ashland • Wood-Fired Pizza Spot • Casual Night-Out Choice
Wood-fired pizzas with a light, blistered crust that feel a little more “night out” than typical carryout joints.
Ohio Fire leans into the appeal of a hot, roaring oven, turning out pies with a tender center and lightly blistered edges. The toppings tend to be a bit more curated, with combinations that go beyond the standard pepperoni-and-mushroom routine. It’s a solid pick when you want to make the short drive from Bailey Lakes for a relaxed evening and a pizza that feels a notch above everyday takeout.