01
Best overall pick
Romeo's Pizza
Tanglewood Square Area • Takeout-Focused Chain Pizzeria • Best For Game-Night Takeout
Reliable, generously topped pies that hit the spot when you just want solid, satisfying pizza fast.
Romeo’s in the Tanglewood Square area is a go-to when Bainbridge families want something everyone will eat without arguing. The crust is on the thicker, chewier side, and they don’t skimp on cheese or toppings, especially on their loaded specialty pies. Add an order of wings or cheesy bread and you’ve got an easy game-night spread ready for pickup or delivery.
02
Most creative pies
Revolution Pizza - Bainbridge
East Washington Street Corridor • Modern Counter-Service Pizza Shop • Creative-Toppings Pick
A local mini-chain known for inventive topping combinations and plenty of build-your-own flexibility.
Revolution Pizza on East Washington leans into fun flavor combinations, from spicy options to veggie-heavy builds that still feel indulgent. The crust runs on the thinner, crisper side, which keeps the pies from feeling too heavy even when you load them up. It’s an easy stop when your group wants to experiment beyond plain pepperoni without getting too fussy about the setting.
03
Family go-to
Zeppe's Pizzeria Bainbridge
Near Route 306 And E Washington • Classic Neighborhood Pizza Joint • Family-Friendly Favorite
Straightforward, crowd-pleasing pizza with plenty of pastas, wings, and subs to round out a family order.
Zeppe’s feels like the local standby you grow up ordering from, with a menu built around classic pies, garlic-heavy breadsticks, and red-sauce pastas. The pizza has a soft, slightly bready crust that works for kids and less adventurous eaters, but you can still get a solid specialty pizza if you want something more loaded. It’s especially handy for feeding a group after activities at the nearby schools and parks.
04
Best pizza and chicken combo
Gionino's Pizzeria - Bainbridge / Chagrin Falls
East Washington Street Strip • Carryout Pizza And Fried Chicken Spot • Best Pizza-And-Chicken Combo
Beloved for pairing hearty, cheese-heavy pies with surprisingly good fried chicken dinners.
Gionino’s is the place locals suggest when you can’t decide between pizza and something more substantial. Their pizzas lean classic Midwest: thick layers of cheese, savory sauces, and a crust sturdy enough to support piled-on toppings. Pair a couple of pies with their crispy JoJo potatoes and chicken for an easy, comfort-food-heavy takeout night.
05
Best sit-down experience
M Italian
Downtown Chagrin Falls • Bustling Italian Restaurant With Wood-Fired Pies • Sit-Down Night-Out Pick
Lively, loft-style Italian spot where wood-fired pizzas share the menu with pastas and antipasti.
A short drive into downtown Chagrin Falls gets you to M Italian, a popular choice when you want pizza but also a proper night out. Their thin, wood-fired crusts come with thoughtful toppings, from simple margherita to richer combos with prosciutto and arugula. Come early or be prepared for a wait, then enjoy a walk to the falls after dinner to round out the evening.