From Main Street in Baltic to the busy crossroads of nearby Sugarcreek, Berlin, and Millersburg, this corner of Ohio has plenty of ways to satisfy a pizza craving. Expect cozy small-town shops, family-friendly chains, and one destination pizzeria locals will happily drive a few extra miles to reach. Whether you want a quick carryout, a sit-down meal, or a solid delivery option back to the farm or cabin, these picks cover the bases.
Baltic’s go-to spot for loaded pies, stromboli, and easy carryout right on Main Street.
If you want pizza without leaving the village, Fox’s is the obvious choice. The menu leans hearty, with generously topped pizzas, wedgies, and wings that travel well for game nights and family gatherings. It’s a straightforward, no-fuss place locals rely on when a craving hits and they want something close to home.
A destination pizzeria known for hand-tossed pies, quality toppings, and a lively small-town atmosphere.
Park Street Pizza is the place people around Baltic talk about when they’re willing to drive for really good pizza. Expect chewy, well-developed crusts, thoughtfully sourced toppings, and combinations that go beyond the usual pepperoni and sausage. The upbeat dining room and consistent takeout make it a top choice for both date nights and post-game team dinners.
Thick-crust pizzas, pasta, and buffet-style options make this an easy stop for feeding a crowd near Berlin’s shops.
Just up the road in Berlin, East of Chicago is a practical pick when you have a hungry group and don’t want to overthink it. The menu covers pan and thin-crust pizzas, pasta, and a salad bar, so everyone can land on something they like. It’s especially handy for youth groups, big families, and tour groups spending the day in Amish Country.
A reliable delivery option when you want hot pizza brought out to your rental, farm, or motel without a long wait.
For late-night cravings or bad-weather evenings, the Domino’s in Millersburg is often the most dependable way to get pizza delivered. The menu is familiar—build-your-own pizzas, specialty pies, bread twists, and chicken—so ordering for a mixed group is simple. It’s not a destination in itself, but it’s a workhorse when convenience and speed matter most.
A classic dine-in spot with pan pizzas, breadsticks, and booths that work well for relaxed family meals.
The Pizza Hut in Millersburg delivers exactly what many families are looking for after a day of errands or exploring Amish Country: familiar pies, plenty of booths, and a low-key pace. Thick, buttery pan crusts and shareable appetizers make it easy to fill the table without breaking the bank. It’s a straightforward, kid-friendly option when you want to linger over pizza instead of rushing back out the door.