Baltimore, Ohio has a quietly excellent pizza scene for a village its size, with longtime locals and travelers sharing the same few go-to shops. Within a short drive you can branch out to lakeside pies and polished city parlors, but it all starts with the slice you grab in town. Use this guide to find the right pie for weeknight takeout, game-day gatherings, or a relaxed night out.
Classic, generously topped pies that taste exactly like a small-town pizza joint should.
Creno's sits right on North Main Street, making it an easy go-to whether you live in town or are just passing through[1]. The crust leans sturdy and chewy, built to handle plenty of toppings without getting soggy. It’s the spot locals rely on for everything from Friday night carryout to post-game team orders.
A community-minded shop known for reliable delivery, crowd-pleasing pies, and plenty of shareable sides.
Cristy’s on South Main feels like the definition of the hometown pizza place that knows its regulars by name[2]. The menu covers all the bases, from simple pepperoni to loaded specialty pies, plus wings and subs to round out a big order. It’s especially handy when you need delivery for a busy weeknight or a house full of hungry kids.
A throwback local restaurant where pizza shares the menu with comforting diner staples.
Arlington Restaurant is one of those no-frills small-town spots where you can grab a pizza, a burger, and a slice of pie under the same roof[5]. The pies are straightforward and satisfying, with a thin, crisp crust that pairs well with a cold drink in a booth. It’s a good pick when you want an unhurried sit-down meal instead of another takeout box.
A popular Buckeye Lake stop with cracker-thin crust, generous cheese, and a fun, casual vibe.
About a short drive east of Baltimore, Pizza Cottage at Buckeye Lake turns pizza night into a mini outing. The Ohio-style thin crust is crisp and light, so you can work through a few different topping combinations without feeling weighed down. Go when you’ve got time to linger over a pie, a salad, and the lake-town atmosphere.
Hearty, topping-loaded pizzas in a busy Lancaster shop that’s become a go-to for Fairfield County pizza runs.
When you’re willing to drive into Lancaster, Pizza Crossing is the spot for a seriously loaded pie. The crust is thicker and more substantial than most nearby shops, with plenty of cheese and toppings piled on top, making it ideal for feeding a group. Order a couple of specialty pizzas, expect leftovers, and consider it a win if you still have slices the next day.