01
Best overall pick
Pizza Milano
St. Clairsville Shopping Corridor • Italian-Style Pizzeria With A Cozy Dine-In Feel • Local Favorite For Classic Pies
A long-running St. Clairsville staple turning out well-balanced, generously topped pizzas just a short drive from Bannock.[3]
Pizza Milano is a go-to when you want a sit-down pizza night with reliably good crust, sauce, and cheese.[3] The menu sticks to Italian-American comfort food, so you can round out your pie with wings, subs, or a simple pasta if you are feeding a mixed crowd.[3] It is an easy choice when you want something that feels local but still works for everyone at the table.
02
Classic local pie
Fabio's Pizza
Central St. Clairsville • No-Frills, Hand-Tossed Pizza Shop • Best For Hearty, Topping-Loaded Slices
A straightforward St. Clairsville pizza shop known for pies piled high with toppings and dependable takeout.[5]
Fabio’s leans into the old-school Ohio pizza shop playbook: chewy, hand-tossed dough, plenty of cheese, and toppings that go right to the edge.[5] It is the kind of place locals order from when they want a filling Friday-night pizza without overthinking it. Call ahead, grab your boxes, and you are back on the road to Bannock in minutes.
03
Easy family takeout
Papa D's Pizza
Neighborhood St. Clairsville • Casual Takeout And Delivery Spot • Best For Family Pizza Night
A laid-back local joint in St. Clairsville that focuses on crowd-pleasing pizzas and straightforward sides.[5]
Papa D’s is built for those nights when you just want a couple of big, shareable pizzas and some wings or breadsticks on the side.[5] Think classic combinations, plenty of cheese, and portions that work well for families or small groups. It is an easy detour on your way back toward Bannock when nobody feels like cooking.
04
Most convenient chain
Domino's Pizza
St. Clairsville Commercial Strip • National Delivery Chain • Best For Late-Night And Fast Delivery
A familiar Domino’s outpost that delivers hot, customizable pizzas across the St. Clairsville area, handy when you are staying near Bannock.[5]
When speed and predictability matter more than tracking down a mom-and-pop shop, the local Domino’s gets the job done.[5] Online ordering, frequent deals, and a wide range of crusts and sauces make it useful for bigger groups or late arrivals into the area. It is the reliable backup plan when other kitchens are closing but you still want a fresh pie on the table.
05
Ohio Valley-style classic
DeFelice Brothers Pizza
Greater Belmont County • Regional Chain With Square-Cut Pies • Best For Sharing With A Crowd
A regional favorite known for square-cut, Ohio Valley-style pizzas that travel well back to Bannock.
DeFelice Brothers is an Ohio Valley standby, with pizzas built on sturdy crusts, tangy sauce, and plenty of cheese cut into easy-to-share squares. The style is made for game days, family gatherings, or any time you are feeding a mix of adults and kids. Order a couple of large pies with a tray of wings and you have a low-stress spread ready as soon as you get home.