01
Best overall pick
Angie’s Italian Restaurant
Central Barberton • Classic Italian Dining Room With Hearty Pizzas • Local Favorite
A Barberton mainstay pairing crisp, cheesy pizzas with a full lineup of comforting Italian dishes.
Opened in the 1950s, Angie’s is the spot many Barberton families think of first when they want pizza and red‑sauce classics in one place. The pies hit that sweet spot of chewy and crisp, loaded with cheese and generous toppings, and the old‑school booths and friendly servers give it a neighborhood‑institution feel. It’s an easy choice when you want a sit‑down meal that still feels casual and welcoming.
02
Best for a laid‑back dinner
Peppe & Luigi’s
East Barberton • Cozy Italian Spot With Classic Pies And Pasta • Comfort‑Food Standout
A low‑key Barberton favorite known for its saucy, cheesy pizzas and no‑rush, family‑style atmosphere.
Peppe & Luigi’s feels like the kind of neighborhood place where people linger over pizza and a basket of garlic bread. The crust is sturdy enough for plenty of toppings, with a sauce that leans savory and a generous hand with the cheese. It’s a great pick when you want an unpretentious sit‑down pizza night without leaving Barberton.
03
Best for families
Papa Roni’s Pizza & Ice Cream
Barberton–Akron Line • Casual Pizzeria With Ice Cream Counter • Kid‑Pleasing Choice
A neighborhood pizzeria that keeps everyone happy with loaded pies, wings, subs, and hand‑scooped ice cream.
Papa Roni’s is built for family takeout nights and casual gatherings, with big pizzas, shareable sides, and the bonus of ice cream for dessert. Expect thickly topped pies, plenty of specialty combinations, and friendly, fast service whether you’re grabbing carryout or getting delivery. It’s especially handy when you need one stop to cover both dinner and a treat.
04
Best nearby takeout
Fat Boy’s Pizza
Norton, Just Southwest Of Barberton • Casual Takeout And Delivery Shop • Hearty Game‑Night Pick
A short drive from Barberton, this Norton shop turns out hefty, topping‑heavy pizzas ideal for sharing.
Fat Boy’s is the place people head when they want a filling pizza run without fuss. The crust leans on the thicker side, built to handle plenty of pepperoni, sausage, and extra cheese, and the menu includes wings and other easy add‑ons. It’s especially popular for game days and laid‑back weekends when you’re ordering for a crowd just outside Barberton proper.
05
Best for pizza and chicken combo
Upper Crust Pizza
Greater Barberton–Akron Area • Takeout And Delivery Pizza And Chicken Joint • Reliable All‑Around Option
A regional favorite for classic pizzas paired with crispy fried chicken and big‑portion sides.
Upper Crust is a go‑to when your group can’t decide between pizza or something else, thanks to a menu that balances pies with fried chicken, salads, and plenty of sides. The pizzas are straightforward and satisfying, with familiar toppings and a crust that holds up well to delivery. It’s a practical choice for mixed‑order nights when you’re feeding different tastes around Barberton.