01
Best overall pick
Home Pizza
Downtown Barnesville • Old-School Hometown Pizzeria • Local Favorite For Classic Pies
A straightforward, no-frills pizza joint turning out hearty pies that taste exactly like small-town Ohio should.[4]
Home Pizza is the kind of classic shop where the menu is short, the portions are big, and the regulars are on a first-name basis.[4] Expect a slightly thicker crust, plenty of cheese, and a sauce that leans comforting over fancy, making it the default choice for Friday nights and family gatherings in town.[4]
02
Best pizza-and-sub combo
Bob's Pizza and Sub Stop
East Barnesville • Counter-Service Pizza And Sub Shop • Best For Takeout Variety
Laid-back and practical, Bob's is where locals go when they want solid pizza plus subs, wings, and sides in one easy stop.[4]
Bob's Pizza and Sub Stop feels built for busy weeknights: order a few pizzas, add a tray of subs, and you’re set for a crowd.[4] The pizza is classic Midwest—cheesy, generously topped, and cut for sharing—while the subs and sides make it a smart choice when not everyone at the table is in a pizza-only mood.[4]
03
Family-friendly chain pick
Fox's Pizza Den
West Barnesville • Family-Friendly Chain Pizzeria • Best For Big-Group Orders
Fox's Pizza Den brings the familiar comfort of a small chain, with customizable pies and big party-sized options that suit teams and family get-togethers.[4]
If you’re feeding a crowd, Fox's Pizza Den is tough to beat, thanks to its giant party pizzas and build-your-own options.[4] The menu runs wide—pizza, wedges, and more—so it works well for birthday parties, team dinners, or any gathering where everyone wants something slightly different.[4]
04
Go-to delivery option
Domino's Pizza
West Main Street, Barnesville • National Delivery Chain • Best For Late-Night And Game Days
Barnesville’s Domino’s on West Main Street makes it easy to get consistent, customizable pizza delivered fast when cooking isn’t in the cards.[1][4]
Domino's is the reliable fallback when you want pizza on the couch, not in a booth, with online ordering and delivery covering most of the Barnesville area.[1][4] The menu goes far beyond basic pepperoni—think specialty pies, stuffed cheesy bread, wings, and desserts—so it’s a simple one-stop order for game days or last-minute gatherings.[1][4]
05
Worth-the-drive classic
DiCarlo's Pizza (St. Clairsville)
St. Clairsville, Near I-70 • Ohio Valley-Style Square-Cut Pizza • Best Regional Standout Nearby
About a half-hour west of Barnesville, DiCarlo's in St. Clairsville is a regional institution known for its unique Ohio Valley-style pizza served in squares.
If you’re up for a short drive, DiCarlo's offers something you simply won’t find at most national chains: a crisp, bakery-style crust with sauce baked on and cheese added after the pan comes out of the oven. The square-cut slices and slightly old-school ordering routine are part of the charm, and many Belmont County pizza fans consider it a must-try at least once. It’s an easy detour off I-70 and a fun way to turn a basic pizza run into a little local food pilgrimage.