01
Classic downtown icon
Reino's Pizza and Pasta
Downtown Tiffin • Old-School Italian Pizzeria • Local Institution
A Tiffin landmark turning out generously topped pies and red-sauce comfort classics in a no-rush dining room.
Reino's is the place locals mention first when you ask where to grab pizza near Bascom. The crust leans classic Midwest—sturdy enough for heavy toppings but still light—and the menu stretches from simple pepperoni to loaded specialty pies and baked pasta. Grab a booth, order a pitcher, and soak in a room that feels unchanged in the best possible way.
02
Best for big groups
Fort Ball Pizza Palace
Riverside Tiffin • Family-Friendly Pizza Palace • Great For Teams And Parties
A sprawling, family-focused spot known for party-size pans, arcade energy, and crowd-pleasing toppings.
Fort Ball Pizza Palace is built for teams rolling in after a game and families who need room to spread out. The pizza comes in big pans with plenty of cheese and classic toppings, plus a buffet-style feel on busy nights. It is the kind of place where kids make a beeline for the games while adults linger over another slice.
03
Hefty carryout favorite
Heavenly Pizza
South Tiffin • Carryout And Delivery Shop • Best For Delivery Night
Known for its jumbo pies and thick, cheesy slices that travel well back to Bascom.
If you are ordering in from Bascom, Heavenly Pizza is often the go-to number to dial. Their signature jumbo pizzas are piled high with toppings, with a slightly thicker crust that stays satisfying even after a drive. Wings, foldovers, and subs round out the order when you are feeding a hungry crowd without leaving the couch.
04
Custom-toppings champ
Marco's Pizza
East Tiffin • Chain Pizzeria With Lots Of Options • Best For Custom Orders
A reliable choice for build-your-own pies, specialty crusts, and quick, online-friendly ordering.
Marco's is a smart pick when everyone wants something a little different. The menu makes it easy to build your own combination, from extra-cheesy thick crusts to lighter, veggie-heavy pies. It is especially handy for last-minute plans, with efficient online ordering and steady delivery times out toward Bascom.
05
Budget-friendly grab-and-go
Little Caesars
West Tiffin • Quick-Service Takeout Chain • Best For Fast, Cheap Slices
Hot-and-ready pizzas make this the easiest stop when you need something filling on the way through town.
For sheer convenience, Little Caesars is tough to beat on a busy weeknight or before a last-minute road trip. You can usually walk in and walk out with a basic pie in just a few minutes, with predictable toppings and that signature buttery crust. It is not fancy, but it reliably fills the gap when you just need pizza, fast, between Bascom and the rest of Tiffin.