01
Best overall pick
Giovanni's Pizza
Barnesville • Classic Small-Town Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A dependable stop for hearty, sauce-forward pies and subs in nearby Barnesville.
Giovanni's hits that sweet spot between familiar and a little bit special, with a crust that stays sturdy under generous toppings and a tangy red sauce locals swear by. It’s the kind of place where a large pepperoni and a couple of salads can easily feed a family without breaking the bank. Call ahead on Friday nights—this spot stays busy when the hometown teams are playing.
02
Most reliable chain option
Pizza Hut
Caldwell, Near The I-77 Exit • Family-Friendly Dine-In Chain • Best For Families
A familiar stop just off the highway with pan pizzas, wings, and space for kids to spread out.
If you’re coming in or out of Noble County on I‑77, the Caldwell Pizza Hut is an easy, predictable choice. The menu is exactly what you’d expect—stuffed crust, pan pizzas, breadsticks, and plenty of shareable sides—so it’s simple to keep a mixed group happy. Grab a booth, let the kids hit the buffet when it’s running, and you’ve got an effortless dinner close to Batesville.
03
Best for Ohio Valley-style
DiCarlo's Pizza
St. Clairsville • Ohio Valley-Style Square-Cut Shop • Regional Classic
Iconic square slices with cheese added after the bake, worth the extra drive from Batesville.
DiCarlo's is a regional institution, and the St. Clairsville location serves the signature Ohio Valley-style pies many people grew up on. Expect a crispy, rectangular crust, a simple tomato base, and freshly added cheese that softens rather than fully melts. It’s a straightforward, nostalgic style of pizza that’s best enjoyed hot in the car or back home before it cools down.
04
Best for big group orders
Cristy's Pizza
Cambridge • Carryout-Focused Local Chain • Great For Sharing
Generous, crowd-pleasing pies that make feeding a group in or near Batesville simple.
Cristy's in Cambridge specializes in big, topping-loaded pizzas that are ideal when you’re ordering for a crew. The crust leans toward the classic Ohio thin-to-medium style, sturdy enough for extra cheese, meats, and veggies without turning soggy. Pair a couple of large specialty pizzas with garlic bread and wings and you’re set for game night or a cabin weekend.
05
Best late-night option
Domino's Pizza
Cambridge • Delivery-First National Chain • Late-Night Pick
Fast, customizable pies and sandwiches that travel well back toward Batesville.
When you need something quick after a long drive or late event, the Cambridge Domino's is usually your fastest bet. The online ordering and tracking make it easy to time pickup for your trip back through Noble County, and the menu has everything from build-your-own pizzas to pastas and chicken bites. Go for a hand-tossed or thin-crust pie if you’re hauling it a bit farther, since they hold up best on the road.