01
Best overall pick
La Pecora Pizzabar
Larchmere District • Wood-Fired Neapolitan-Style Pizzeria • Best For Date Night
A stylish Larchmere spot turning out blistered, wood-fired pies with seasonal toppings in a buzzy, intimate room.
La Pecora Pizzabar feels like a little slice of the modern Italian pizza scene dropped just west of Beachwood. The menu leans into thoughtfully sourced ingredients and a short list of creative pies, backed by good wine and cocktails. It’s an easy choice when you want pizza to feel like a proper night out rather than just takeout.
02
For pizza purists
Vero Pizza Napoletana
Cedar-Fairmount • Intimate Neapolitan Pizza Bar • Serious Pie Destination
Tiny, focused, and all about the leopard-spotted crust, Vero is where east-siders go when they crave classic Neapolitan pizza.
Vero keeps the focus squarely on the dough, the oven, and a tight lineup of toppings, turning out soft-centered, char-kissed pies in a cozy space overlooking Cedar Hill. The menu is short but dialed in, so it’s easy to zero in on a margherita or one of the rotating specials. Head here when you care more about perfect crust and simple ingredients than a long list of extras.
03
Old-school classic
Geraci's Restaurant
University Heights • Family-Run Red-Sauce Italian Joint • Local Institution
A fixture for generations, Geraci's is known for its cheesy, square-cut pies and warm, no-rush dining room.
Geraci's has been a go-to for east-side families long before Beachwood’s current boom, and its pizza is a big reason why. Expect that classic Cleveland style: a sturdy, flavor-packed crust, plenty of cheese, and a tangy sauce, often cut into squares. It’s the kind of place where multi-generational groups linger over pizza, antipasti, and a carafe of wine without feeling hurried.
04
Best for groups
Pizzazz on the Circle
Fairmount Circle • Lively Neighborhood Pizza Pub • Game-Day Hangout
Casual and bustling near John Carroll, Pizzazz balances crisp-crust pizzas with a full bar and plenty of room for a crowd.
Just a short hop from Beachwood, Pizzazz on the Circle draws a mix of students, families, and longtime regulars with its well-loaded pies and relaxed pub feel. The crust lands in that sweet spot between thin and doughy, sturdy enough to support generous toppings without getting soggy. It’s an easy pick for birthday dinners, team outings, or catching a game with pizza and a round of drinks.
05
Reliable takeout
Marco's Pizza – Chagrin Blvd
Chagrin Blvd Corridor • Quick-Service Carryout And Delivery Shop • Weeknight Takeout Hero
Beachwood’s Marco's turns out consistent, crowd-pleasing pies with the convenience of fast carryout or delivery.
When you need pizza on the table quickly, the Chagrin Boulevard Marco’s is hard to beat for convenience. The menu covers all the bases—from classic pepperoni to build-your-own combinations—so everyone in the group can get what they want. It’s a dependable choice for busy weeknights, office lunches, or feeding a hungry crew after a long day.