01
Best overall pick
Old Scratch Pizza
Dayton-Xenia Road Corridor • Lively Wood-Fired Neapolitan Pizzeria • Best For Groups And Craft Beer
Fast-fired pies, a deep tap list, and a busy patio make Old Scratch a go-to Beavercreek hangout.
The Beavercreek outpost of Old Scratch turns out blistered, charred-edge pizzas with inventive toppings alongside well-executed classics. Long communal tables and an indoor-outdoor bar give it a buzzy, casual feel that works for families, date nights, or big groups. On nice evenings, the patio with fire pits is one of the most social spots on this side of town.
02
Best for beer lovers
Pies & Pints
The Greene Town Center • Craft-Beer Focused Pizza Bar • Best For Pizza And Pints After Shopping
Creative topping combos and an impressive draft list make Pies & Pints a natural stop at The Greene.
Set in the heart of The Greene Town Center, Pies & Pints pairs chewy, stone-baked crusts with toppings that lean playful—think specialty pies loaded with fresh ingredients and bold flavors. The beer list is a draw on its own, with rotating taps that reward repeat visits. It’s an easy choice for meeting friends after a movie, a shopping run, or a night out on the patio.
03
Best neighborhood secret
Beavercreek Pizza Dive
Short Drive East In Xenia • Casual, Toppings-Heavy Pizzeria • Best For Big, Shareable Takeout
Beavercreek Pizza Dive is the place locals call when they want hefty pies loaded edge-to-edge with toppings.
Despite the name, this independent shop sits just east of Beavercreek and draws regulars from across the area. The menu leans toward generous portions, thick layers of cheese, and specialty pizzas that feel custom-built for game nights and parties. It’s not fancy, but the friendly crew and consistently over-the-top pies are exactly what many people want from a hometown pizza joint.
04
Classic Dayton-style choice
Marion's Piazza
North Fairfield Road Strip • Classic Dayton-Style Thin-Crust Parlor • Local Institution For Families And Teams
Marion’s serves ultra-thin, square-cut pies in a big, no-frills dining room that feels straight out of Dayton’s pizza history.
For many Beavercreek families, Marion’s is the default choice for birthday parties, post-game team meals, and casual Friday nights. The signature ultra-thin crust, finely crumbled toppings, and trademark square cut are pure Dayton nostalgia. Add in quick service, plenty of seating, and a familiar order-at-the-counter setup, and it’s easy to see why generations keep coming back.
05
Best for varied menu
MacKenzie River Pizza, Grill & Pub
Near Fairfield Commons • Rustic Lodge-Style Pizza Grill • Best When Not Everyone Wants Pizza
MacKenzie River offers creative pies in a cozy lodge setting, plus burgers, pastas, and salads for non-pizza folks.
Just off Fairfield Commons Boulevard, MacKenzie River feels more like a mountain lodge than a typical chain. The pizza lineup ranges from familiar builds to signature combinations with thoughtful sauces and toppings, making it easy to find a favorite. With a full bar and a broad menu that includes hearty entrees and lighter options, it’s a reliable pick for mixed groups and family dinners.