Bellaire • best pizza

5 Best Pizzerias & Pizza Places for Bellaire Ohio

Bellaire’s pizza scene punches above its weight, mixing classic family recipes with quick, no-fuss slice shops and dependable delivery. Most of the action hugs Belmont Street, but a short hop to nearby river towns opens up even more options. Whether you want a slow sit-down meal, a box for game night, or a late bite after work, these five spots are where locals start.

View List Contact Us

01 Best overall pick

Lil' Gerardo's

Belmont Street In Central Bellaire • Family-Run Pizzeria And Italian Eatery • Local Favorite

A cozy staple where Bellaire locals head for hearty pies and classic Italian comfort food.

Lil' Gerardo's feels like the kind of place where they know your order by heart, thanks to loyal regulars and a small-town, family-run vibe. The pizzas are generous and saucy with a sturdy crust that holds up well under toppings, and the menu branches out into pastas and subs when you want more than a slice. It gets busy on weekend evenings, so calling ahead can save you some waiting around.

02 Best for late-night cravings

24/7 Pizza

Belmont Street Near The North End Of Town • Counter-Service Slice And Pie Shop • Late-Night Pick

Straightforward, satisfying pies that hit the spot when you want something hot and fast.

24/7 Pizza leans into convenience, with quick-turnaround pies and slices that are all about familiar flavors done simply. Expect classic topping combos, thick-cut pepperoni, and crusts that are more about soak-up-the-sauce comfort than fussy presentation. It is the kind of spot you rely on after a long shift or when you need an easy pick for movie night without overthinking it.

03 Most reliable delivery

Domino's Pizza

Belmont Street Strip In Bellaire • National Delivery Chain • Best For Fast Delivery

A go-to for consistent, customizable pizzas that show up fast when you do not feel like leaving the house.

Bellaire’s Domino’s is a workhorse for busy families and anyone craving predictable comfort food on a tight schedule. Between the mix-and-match deals, specialty pies, and build-your-own options, it is easy to feed a crowd without breaking the bank. App ordering and tracking make it especially handy on bad-weather nights when staying in is the whole plan.

04 Best for gourmet toppings

Around the World Gourmet Marketplace

Second Avenue Near The Riverfront • Gourmet Market And Takeout Pizzeria • Best For Adventurous Eaters

Creative, loaded pies with a gourmet streak, plus wings, subs, and market extras under one roof.

Around the World Gourmet Marketplace feels a bit different from your typical corner pizza shop, with a menu that plays around with sauces, cheeses, and toppings you do not see everywhere. It is a strong choice when you want something beyond pepperoni, like specialty combinations or add-ons from the market side. Grab a couple of pizzas, some wings, and a few extras, and you have an easy spread for a small get-together.

05 Worth-the-drive classic

DeFelice Bros. Pizza – Shadyside

Short Drive South To Shadyside • Regional Ohio Valley Pizza Chain • Best For Big Groups

A nearby regional favorite known for loaded, shareable pies and crowd-pleasing sides.

If you do not mind a few minutes in the car, DeFelice Bros. in Shadyside is a solid option when you are feeding a bigger crew. The pizzas lean hearty, with plenty of cheese and toppings, plus thick-cut squares that are easy to pass around. Round it out with appetizers, salads, and subs and you have a one-stop order for game day or family gatherings just outside Bellaire.