01
Best overall pick
Wally's Pizza and Sub
Caldwell Village Center • Old-School Pizzeria And Sub Shop • Local Favorite For Big Groups
Generous pies, straightforward toppings, and friendly service make Wally's feel like the classic small-town pizza joint.
If you ask around Noble County for a dependable pizza, Wally's is the name that comes up first. The crust is sturdy enough for loaded toppings, and the sauce leans savory rather than sweet, which locals appreciate. It is an easy stop when you are in Caldwell, with plenty of space for families and teams to spread out over a couple of large pies.
02
Best for customizable pies
Plus 1 Pizza
Just Off Main Street In Caldwell • Casual Carryout And Delivery Spot • Top Pick For Takeout
Plus 1 is where locals go when they want to build their own pie with lots of topping combinations and quick turnaround.
This Caldwell outpost of Plus 1 Pizza has the hometown chain feel down to a science: consistent crust, plenty of cheese, and a long list of toppings. It is especially handy if you are staying in or around Belle Valley and want something easy to bring back to the house or campsite. Call ahead on busy evenings, as regulars lean on this place for game nights and family gatherings.
03
Best late-night option
Domino's Pizza
Caldwell North Side • National Chain With A Local Crew • Most Reliable For Late-Night Delivery
When other kitchens have closed, the Caldwell Domino's usually still has the ovens running and drivers on the road.
While it is a familiar national name, the Caldwell Domino's is a real workhorse for Noble County residents. The online ordering and tracking make it easy to line up a delivery back to Belle Valley after a long day on the road or the river. It is not trying to be gourmet, but for consistent crust, predictable flavors, and late hours, it earns its place on the list.
04
Worth-the-drive classic
Morgano's Pizza
Byesville Village Center • Family-Run Italian-American Pizzeria • Best For Hearty Comfort Food
Morgano's serves thick, cheesy pies and classic sides that feel tailor-made for a small-town Friday night.
About a short drive north of Belle Valley, Morgano's in Byesville is the kind of place that has been feeding local families for years. The crust is on the thicker side with a good chew, and the toppings are layered generously, so a couple of pizzas go a long way. Pair it with wings or a salad and you have an easy, comforting meal after a day exploring the back roads of Noble and Guernsey counties.
05
Best sit-down choice
Guido's Pizza & Pasta
Downtown Cambridge • Full-Service Italian Restaurant And Pizzeria • Best For A Relaxed Night Out
Guido's combines well-made pizza with a fuller Italian menu, making it a good choice when not everyone at the table wants the same thing.
If you are willing to go a little farther from Belle Valley, downtown Cambridge rewards you with Guido's, a long-running spot that feels lively on weekends. Pizzas come with a flavorful, slightly sweet sauce and plenty of topping options, but you can also branch out into pasta and appetizers. It is a good pick when you want a proper sit-down meal with pizza at the center but more choices around it.