01
Best overall pick
Six Hundred Downtown
Downtown Bellefontaine • Brick-Oven Pizzeria And Bar • Destination For Pizza Purists
A nationally recognized wood-fired shop in a historic downtown storefront, serving meticulously crafted pies with serious attention to dough.
Six Hundred Downtown is the place locals mention first when you ask about great pizza in Bellefontaine. The menu leans into classic and specialty pies built on long-fermented dough, blistered in a hot stone oven for real Neapolitan-style character. Expect a lively, slightly upscale-but-casual feel that works just as well for date night as for a relaxed dinner with friends.
02
Reliable chain favorite
Donatos Pizza
South Main Retail Strip • Carryout And Delivery Chain • Best For Game-Night Carryout
Crisp, edge-to-edge topping pizzas that locals lean on for easy pickup or delivery when feeding a crowd.
Bellefontaine’s Donatos offers the same thin, crispy crust and generous toppings the regional chain is known for, making it a dependable choice when you want exactly what you expect. It’s especially handy for sports nights, parties, or office lunches when timing and consistency matter. Order ahead, grab your boxes, and you’re back on the road in minutes.
03
Best for groups
Vicario's Pizza
South Bellefontaine • Buffet-Friendly Hometown Shop • Value Pick For Big Appetites
A laid-back local spot known for hearty pizzas, generous portions, and an easygoing, family-ready vibe.
Vicario’s feels like the kind of place regulars grow up with: straightforward pies, plenty of cheese, and no fuss. It’s a solid option when you’re feeding a larger group and want good value without sacrificing flavor. Grab a mix of classic toppings, add some sides, and you’ve got an easy dinner that keeps everyone full.
04
Family-friendly favorite
Fat Boy's Pizza & Ice Cream
East Bellefontaine • Family Pizza And Ice Cream Parlor • Top Spot For Families With Kids
Casual, kid-pleasing pizzas paired with ice cream treats in a relaxed, family-first setting.
Fat Boy’s is the kind of all-in-one stop that makes family nights easy: order a few pizzas, let the kids pick out ice cream, and settle in without worrying about formality. The crusts are hearty, toppings are familiar, and the atmosphere is friendly and unpretentious. It’s especially good for younger families who want a low-stress outing close to home.
05
Local sleeper hit
B-Town Pizza
North Side Neighborhood • Casual Neighborhood Slice Shop • Under-The-Radar Local Gem
A straightforward, no-frills pizza joint that wins people over with consistent pies and a true local-spot feel.
B-Town Pizza flies a bit under the radar compared with better-known names, but many locals swear by its well-balanced pies and friendly service. It’s the kind of neighborhood place where staff remember repeat orders and keep things simple. If you like supporting low-key, independently minded shops, put this one on your short list.