01
Best overall pick
Fast Eddie's Pizza
Downtown Bellville • Classic Pizza And Italian Counter-Service Spot • Community Go-To For Big Orders
Fast Eddie’s is the Bellville standby for generous pies, baked subs, and family-size orders that don’t skimp on toppings.
If you ask around town where to order pizza for a crowd, Fast Eddie’s is the name you’ll hear most. The crust strikes a happy middle ground between soft and crisp, with plenty of cheese and toppings that feel substantial rather than sparse. With a menu that also covers pastas, subs, and salads, it’s an easy, budget-friendly option whether you’re feeding a team or just grabbing a Friday-night delivery.
02
Coziest local hangout
Brumby's Coffeehouse & Pizzeria
Bellville Village Center • Coffeehouse And Small-Town Pizzeria • Best For A Relaxed Sit-Down Slice
Brumby’s blends a laid-back coffeehouse feel with surprisingly solid pizza, making it an easy place to linger over a pie.
Set in a historic building right on Main Street, Brumby’s feels more like a living room than a restaurant, with comfy seating and a slower pace. The pizza leans comforting rather than fussy, with a soft, chewy crust and plenty of classic topping combinations that pair well with a latte or cold drink. It’s the spot to choose when you’d rather sit and chat over a fresh-baked pie than rush home with a box.
03
Retro road-trip slice
Leaning Tower of Pizza
South Mansfield Corridor • Old-School Italian-American Pizzeria • Classic Pick For A Night Out
A short drive from Bellville, Leaning Tower of Pizza serves thin, party-cut pies in a throwback dining room that hasn’t lost its charm.
This Mansfield institution feels like stepping into an earlier era, complete with red-check accents and big plates of pizza and pasta. The pies are thin, Ohio-style rounds cut into squares, with crisp edges and a slightly sweet sauce that regulars swear by. It’s a great choice when you want to turn pizza into a sit-down outing rather than a quick carry-out run.
04
Downtown favorite
Two Cousins' Pizza Co.
Downtown Mansfield • Casual Slice Shop And Italian Eatery • Best For Quick Slices And Lunch
Two Cousins’ in downtown Mansfield offers hearty slices, whole pies, and Italian staples that work perfectly for a quick lunch or pre-event bite.
Located near Mansfield’s downtown attractions, Two Cousins’ is a convenient stop when you’re already in town for a show, game, or errands. The pizza is straightforward and satisfying, with a sturdy crust that holds up well to extra toppings and plenty of cheese. Add in stromboli, wings, and salads, and it becomes the flexible option when everyone in the group wants something a little different.
05
Best value carry-out
Deschner's Pizza
East Mansfield Neighborhood • Carry-Out And Delivery Pizza Shop • Budget-Friendly Family Choice
Deschner’s is a low-key Mansfield shop known for square-cut pies, deals on larger orders, and friendly, no-nonsense service.
This is the kind of place that has quietly kept local families fed for years: simple menu, reliable timing, and pizza that travels well back to Bellville. The crust is on the thicker side and cut into squares, with a balanced sauce and classic toppings that please most palates. When you’re watching the budget but still want enough pizza to cover a movie night or sleepover, Deschner’s is worth the short drive.