01
Best overall pick
Papa D's Pizza
Belmont Village • Classic Small-Town Pizzeria • Local Favorite
The go-to Belmont spot for straightforward, generously topped pizzas and easy weeknight takeout.
Tucked right in Belmont, Papa D's is the place most locals mention first when you ask about pizza in town. The menu leans classic—think loaded pepperoni, sausage, and extra cheese—with hearty portions that make it an easy choice for feeding a crowd. It’s a no-fuss operation with friendly service, so you’re in and out quickly with a hot box in hand.
02
Best highway-side surprise
Pilot Pizza (Pilot Travel Center)
Belmont–Morristown Rd / I-70 Exit • Convenient Counter-Style Pizza • Best Quick Bite
A surprisingly solid grab-and-go pizza option right off I-70, popular with both truckers and locals on the move.
Inside the Pilot Travel Center along Belmont–Morristown Road, this counter serves hot, ready-to-go pizzas that are better than you might expect from a fuel stop. Slices and whole pies come out fast, making it ideal when you’re hopping on or off the interstate. It’s not a sit-down pizzeria, but for road-trip snacks, late-night shifts, or a quick slice between errands, it does the job well.
03
Most reliable nearby classic
Fabio's Pizza
Saint Clairsville • Family-Friendly Italian Pizza Shop • Worth-The-Drive Pick
A long-running St. Clairsville favorite known for its classic pies, Italian comfort food, and friendly, family-style atmosphere.
Just a short drive west in Saint Clairsville, Fabio's is the kind of place people grow up with and keep coming back to. The crust lands in that satisfying middle ground—sturdy enough to hold toppings, but still soft and chewy—and the sauce leans savory without being too sweet. It’s a comfortable spot for dine-in or carryout when you want something a step up from basic takeout without getting fancy.
04
Best carryout variety
Papa D's Pizza (St. Clairsville)
Saint Clairsville • Casual Carryout And Delivery Shop • Best For Big Orders
A busy outpost with a broad menu of pizzas, subs, and sides that’s built for feeding groups around St. Clairsville and Belmont.
This sister location to Belmont’s hometown shop gives you a wider selection and easy access from the shopping and hotels near I-70. Beyond the familiar pizzas, you’ll find wings, subs, and plenty of sides, which makes it handy for game-day spreads or family get-togethers. Order ahead on busy evenings—locals know it’s one of the first places to get slammed when everyone wants delivery at once.
05
Most dependable chain option
Domino's Pizza
Saint Clairsville • National Delivery Chain • Best Late-Night Delivery
A familiar chain shop that covers Belmont and nearby communities with consistent pies, late hours, and online ordering.
When you want something predictable and fast, the St. Clairsville Domino’s is the chain many locals rely on, especially later in the evening. The menu covers the usual suspects—custom pies, specialty combinations, wings, pasta, and desserts—so everyone in the group can find something. It’s not trying to be gourmet, but for reliable delivery to homes and hotels around Belmont, it earns its spot on the list.