01
Best overall pick
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill
Ottawa – East End • Family-Friendly Pizza & Grill • Local Favorite
Big, shareable pizzas and a lively, sports-bar feel make Beer Barrel an easy choice for a group outing.
This Ottawa outpost of a regional favorite is where many locals default for pizza nights, especially when they’re feeding a crowd. Crusts are sturdy enough to hold generous toppings, and the menu stretches well beyond pizza, so non-pizza people are covered. It’s an especially good call when you want a sit-down meal with plenty of TVs and a relaxed, casual atmosphere.
02
Best classic takeout pie
Pisanello's Pizza
Ottawa – Downtown • Classic Small-Town Pizzeria • Best For Takeout
A long-running local chain spot known for dependable, saucy pies and generous toppings.
Pisanello’s in Ottawa feels like the kind of place every northwest Ohio town grows up with: a straightforward counter, friendly staff, and pizza that hits the spot on a weeknight. The crust leans toward soft and bready, with plenty of cheese and a sweeter red sauce that regulars swear by. Call ahead, grab a couple of larges and breadsticks, and you’re set for an easy night back in Belmore.
03
Best nostalgic stop
Jac & Do's Pizza
Ottawa – West Side • Old-School Ohio Pizza Shop • Neighborhood Staple
A no-frills local chain turning out thin, slightly crispy pies that taste like small-town Ohio in a box.
Jac & Do’s has a devoted following across the region, and the Ottawa shop is no exception. The pizza is all about simple toppings, a slightly crisp crust, and that unmistakable Ohio-style cheese pull. It’s an easy swing through town from Belmore, especially if you’re after something unfussy that feels like it’s been part of local life for decades.
04
Best loaded specialty pizzas
Heavenly Pizza
Findlay – North Side • Casual Carryout And Delivery Spot • Best For Variety
Heavenly Pizza is known for hefty specialty pies and a crust that holds up under serious toppings.
If you don’t mind a longer drive from Belmore, Heavenly Pizza in Findlay rewards you with one of the area’s deeper menus. Think meat-heavy combos, veggie-loaded options, and plenty of add-ons, from flavored crusts to cheesy sides. It’s a smart choice when you’re feeding a mix of tastes and want more than just pepperoni and cheese on the table.
05
Best quick stop off the highway
Padrone's Pizza
North Baltimore – Main Street • Small-Town Carryout Pizzeria • Road-Trip Friendly
Just east of Belmore, Padrone’s offers reliable, hot-from-the-oven pies perfect for grabbing on the way home.
Set in North Baltimore’s compact downtown, this outpost of Padrone’s is popular with locals and drivers hopping off I-75. The pizza leans classic Ohio-style with a medium crust, plenty of cheese, and straightforward toppings. It’s a handy option when you’re coming back toward Belmore and want to pick up dinner without detouring through a bigger city.