Bentleyville sits in a sweet spot between Chagrin Falls, Solon, and Bainbridge, which means excellent pizza is never more than a short drive away. From cozy neighborhood joints to buzzy taverns with serious pies, the East Side has a slice for every mood. Use this list to zero in on the right spot whether you’re grabbing takeout after a hike in the Metroparks or lingering over a night out.
A compact Chagrin Falls staple turning out thoughtfully made pies with a true neighborhood feel.
Pizzeria DiLauro is the kind of spot locals recommend first when you ask where to get really good pizza near Bentleyville. The crust hits that sweet spot between chewy and crisp, with just enough char to keep things interesting. Classic toppings are done well here, so a simple pepperoni or margherita is often the best move.
A lively tavern where wood-fired pizzas share the spotlight with a strong bar program and seasonal dishes.
Crumb & Spigot feels more like a destination than a quick slice stop, but the pizza is a big part of the draw. The pies come out of a high-heat oven with nicely blistered crusts and more cheffy topping combinations than you’ll find at a typical carryout shop. It’s a smart pick when you want pizza plus good cocktails or craft beer in one place.
A no-frills East Side standby for saucy, cheese-laden pies and hearty sides to feed a crowd.
Augie’s leans into that classic Northeast Ohio style: plenty of cheese, a generous ladle of sauce, and square-cut pies that are easy to share. It’s the place you call when the game is on, the kids are hungry, and nobody wants to cook. Add in ribs, wings, and other familiar comfort-food staples and you’ve got an easy one-stop order from Bentleyville.
A modern pizzeria known for its long menu, customizable pies, and options for nearly every diet at the table.
Revolution Pizza is a boon for mixed groups, with everything from straightforward cheese and pepperoni to specialty combinations and build-your-own options. They typically offer alternative crusts and toppings that work well for gluten-conscious or vegetarian eaters, which makes planning a group order much easier. It’s an easy hop from Bentleyville via the main east–west routes.
A reliable Solon outpost of a local chain, built for big orders, specialty pies, and straightforward crowd-pleasers.
The Solon location of Master Pizza is a go-to for many East Side families when they need to feed a lot of people fast. The menu leans into loaded specialty pizzas, from meat-heavy options to veggie-forward combinations, along with wings and salads to round things out. It’s especially handy for team parties, birthday gatherings, or any night when convenience matters as much as the slice.