01
Best overall pick
Paradise Pizza
Main Street, Benton Ridge • Small-Town Carryout Pizzeria • Local Favorite
The Benton Ridge outpost of Paradise Pizza is the go-to spot in the village for classic, no-nonsense pies.
Sitting right on Main Street, Paradise Pizza feels like the kind of place everyone in town has on speed dial. The menu leans into familiar toppings and hearty portions, with reliable crust and sauce that hit the spot after a long day. It’s the easiest choice when you want good pizza without leaving Benton Ridge.
02
Best for delivery to Benton Ridge
Heavenly Pizza
East Side Findlay • Family-Friendly Delivery And Carryout Shop • Best For Easy Delivery
Heavenly Pizza in Findlay is known for generous toppings, friendly service, and a delivery area that reaches Benton Ridge.
If you’d rather stay home, Heavenly Pizza is a strong option thanks to its broad delivery range that covers many small towns around Findlay. The crust is sturdy enough for loaded specialty pies, and the menu includes subs and sides that make it easy to feed a crowd. It’s a dependable weeknight choice when you want dinner to show up at the door still hot.
03
Best for creative toppings
Dougie’s Pizza Co.
Tiffin Avenue Corridor, Findlay • Modern Fast-Casual Pizzeria • Great For Variety
Dougie’s Pizza Co. in Findlay mixes classic comfort with more adventurous topping combinations in a bright, casual setting.
Located along the busy Tiffin Avenue strip, Dougie’s is worth the short drive when you want to switch things up from the usual pepperoni. You’ll find inventive specialty pies alongside build-your-own options with plenty of sauces, cheeses, and toppings. It’s a good pick for groups who all want something a little different without sacrificing quality.
04
Best classic Findlay staple
Jac & Do’s Pizza
Downtown-Adjacent Findlay • Old-School Ohio Pizzeria • Classic Hometown Spot
Jac & Do’s is a long-running Findlay favorite, known for its thin, crispy crust and nostalgic small-town pizzeria feel.
This is the kind of place many Hancock County locals grew up with, and it still pulls steady traffic on busy evenings. The pizzas are straightforward and satisfying, with a crust that bakes up crisp and a tangy sauce that keeps slices from feeling too heavy. Grab a pie here when you’re craving that familiar, old-school Ohio pizza experience a short drive from Benton Ridge.
05
Best sit-down option
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill
East-Side Shopping Area, Findlay • Lively Pizza And Grill Restaurant • Best For Groups
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill pairs crowd-pleasing pan and thin-crust pizzas with a full menu and plenty of seating.
Set near the retail and hotel cluster on the east side of Findlay, this spot is ideal when you want more than a quick carryout run. The pizzas are hearty, with thick layers of cheese and toppings, and there’s a long list of appetizers, salads, and sandwiches to keep everyone happy. It’s a convenient choice for meeting up with friends or grabbing pizza after a day of errands in town.