01
Best overall pick
Table Rock Pizzeria
Central Berlin • Casual Brick-Oven Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A Berlin staple for generous, well-charred pies with plenty of toppings and a relaxed small-town feel.
Table Rock is the place locals send you when you ask where to get pizza in Berlin. The crust has enough chew to stand up to hearty toppings, and the sauce leans flavorful rather than overly sweet. It’s a comfortable stop after a day of shopping, with easygoing service and a menu that keeps both traditional and build-your-own fans happy.
02
Worth-the-drive destination
Park Street Pizza
Downtown Sugarcreek • Craft Pizzeria With Modern Flair • Destination For Food-Focused Visitors
A short drive from Berlin, Park Street turns out creative, carefully made pizzas that feel a notch above typical small-town pies.
If you’re serious about pizza, Park Street in Sugarcreek is worth planning an evening around. They pay attention to details: a well-developed crust, quality toppings, and combinations that go beyond the usual pepperoni-and-cheese routine. It’s a lively spot that works just as well for a date night as it does for a post-sightseeing group dinner.
03
Coziest in-town option
Colorful Cookery
Historic Berlin Center • Eclectic Café With Pizza On The Menu • Best For A Relaxed Sit-Down Meal
Set in one of Berlin’s older buildings, this café serves homey pizzas alongside other comfort-food favorites.
Colorful Cookery feels more like a hometown café than a dedicated slice shop, but their pizzas are a pleasant surprise. The crust is straightforward and satisfying, and the toppings are handled with a home-cooked touch rather than a fast-food rush. It’s a good choice if you want pizza but some of your group is craving salads, sandwiches, or daily specials too.
04
Best for groups
East of Chicago Pizza (Millersburg)
Downtown Millersburg • Buffet-Style And Carryout Pizza Shop • Best For Families And Big Appetites
A familiar regional chain that’s handy when you need plenty of pizza fast for families or larger groups.
East of Chicago in nearby Millersburg is the dependable choice when headcount matters more than hunting for a hidden gem. The crust options, from pan to thin, make it easy to please different tastes, and the buffet setup (when running) keeps kids and hungry adults satisfied without a long wait. It’s the kind of place locals turn to for team parties, casual gatherings, and easy carryout nights.
05
Most kid-friendly pick
Pizza Hut (Millersburg)
North Millersburg • Classic National-Chain Pizzeria • Best For Familiar Favorites
A reliable stop for the pan pizzas, breadsticks, and wings families already know and expect.
When you’ve got picky eaters in the car, the Pizza Hut in Millersburg is an easy win. The menu is exactly what most travelers expect, from thick, cheesy pan pies to simple personal pizzas that keep kids happy. It’s not the most adventurous option near Berlin, but it’s convenient, predictable, and useful as a backup plan when local spots are packed or closed.