01
Best overall pick
The Wood Fired Pizza Company
Bethesda Countryside • Mobile Wood-Fired Pizzeria • Destination For Artisan Pies
A locally loved wood-fired operation turning out blistered, flavorful pies that feel surprisingly big-city for such a quiet corner of Belmont County.
When you want something that feels a little special without driving to a bigger town, The Wood Fired Pizza Company is the move. The crust comes out with a good char and chew, and the toppings lean classic but are always fresh and generous. It’s the kind of place locals watch for on social media and plan their weeknights around when the oven is fired up.
02
Classic Ohio Valley slices
DiCarlo's Pizza
Uptown St. Clairsville • Ohio Valley Square-Cut Shop • Old-School Local Icon
A short drive from Bethesda gets you to those unmistakable DiCarlo’s squares with sauce baked on and cheese added right before the box closes.
If you grew up anywhere in the Ohio Valley, DiCarlo’s is more comfort food than restaurant choice. The crust is thin and crisp, the sauce has a little tang, and the cheese goes on after the bake so it just softens over the hot slices. Order a tray, eat a few pieces in the car while they’re still scorching, and you’ll understand why locals defend this style so fiercely.
03
Heaviest on toppings
DeFelice Bros. Pizza
Shadyside Riverfront • Neighborhood Pizza And Subs Shop • Best For Loaded Specialty Pies
DeFelice Bros. is the spot when you want a thick layer of toppings, plenty of cheese, and a crust sturdy enough to hold it all together.
Shadyside is a bit of a drive, but many Bethesda folks make the trip when they’re craving a hearty, old-school pie. DeFelice Bros. leans into generous toppings, especially on their specialty pizzas, and the dough has enough body to stay crisp under the weight. Add in subs and wings and it becomes an easy one-stop option for feeding a bigger group on game night.
04
Reliable family stop
Pizza Hut
Ohio Valley Mall Corridor • Sit-Down Chain Restaurant • Best For Families
A familiar dine-in and carryout choice with pan pizzas, breadsticks, and enough menu variety to keep everyone at the table happy.
For Bethesda families who want a predictable sit-down experience without heading to a city, the St. Clairsville Pizza Hut fits the bill. The classic pan crust is still the draw, but kids tend to latch onto the breadsticks and personal pizzas. It’s also an easy stop to pair with a mall run, making it a practical choice for weekends and school breaks.
05
Fastest turnaround
Domino's Pizza
East St. Clairsville • National Delivery Chain • Late-Night And Game-Day Go-To
When speed, tracking the order on your phone, and late-night hours matter more than atmosphere, Domino’s is the reliable option nearby.
Domino’s in St. Clairsville is the workhorse choice for Bethesda residents who care about quick delivery and consistent results. The hand-tossed and thin crusts travel well, and the menu covers everything from basic pepperoni to build-your-own combinations, plus wings and sandwiches. It’s the spot you call when kickoff is in an hour and no one feels like cooking.