01
Best overall pick
Jim's Pizza Box
Downtown Vermilion • Classic Small-Town Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A Vermilion standby turning out generous, well-topped pies that hit the spot after a day on the lake.
Jim's Pizza Box is the kind of place locals grow up on, with a crisp-but-chewy crust and plenty of cheese on every slice. The menu runs from straightforward pepperoni to loaded specialty pies, plus subs and wings if not everyone at the table is in a pizza mood. It’s an easy, reliable choice when you want a satisfying, no-fuss pizza night close to the water.
02
Best for families
Papa Joe's Pizza & Pies
East Vermilion • Family Pizzeria And Bakery-Style Shop • Best For Families
Laid-back and kid-friendly, with hearty pizzas and plenty of shareable comfort food.
Papa Joe’s leans into big portions and a welcoming, all-ages vibe that works well for beach crews and family gatherings. Pizzas come with a slightly thicker crust and a generous spread of toppings, plus there are strombolis, pastas, and desserts to round out the meal. It’s the spot to pick when you need something everyone will agree on without driving far from Beulah Beach.
03
Most creative pies
Woodstock Cafe
Vermilion Main Street • Casual Café With Artisan-Style Pizzas • Best For A Relaxed Night Out
A cozy café atmosphere with more creative, café-style pizzas and good options for lingering over a meal.
Woodstock Café brings a slightly more eclectic touch to the local pizza scene, with topping combinations that go beyond the usual pepperoni-and-mushroom routine. Expect a thinner crust, fresher toppings, and a menu that often includes seasonal or veggie-forward options. It’s a nice pick if you want something a bit different from a typical pizzeria without leaving the Vermilion area.
04
Closest classic to the beach
Huron Pizza House
Huron – Riverside • Old-School Neighborhood Pizza Joint • Best Quick Stop From Beulah Beach
Straightforward, old-school pies and subs just a short drive west in Huron.
Huron Pizza House is the sort of unfussy corner spot where the focus stays on hot, fresh pizza and friendly service. The crust tends toward the classic Midwest style—sturdy enough for plenty of toppings but not overly thick. It’s a convenient choice when you’re leaving the beach and want to grab a couple of pies to go without detouring into the bigger cities.
05
Best for big groups
Chet & Matt's Pizza
Sandusky – Cleveland Road • Lively Sports Bar And Pizzeria • Great For Groups And Game Nights
A spacious Sandusky favorite known for its big specialty pizzas, buffet nights, and game-day energy.
Chet & Matt’s is worth the slightly longer drive if you’re traveling with a crowd or want a full evening out. The menu spans hefty specialty pizzas, wings, and appetizers, and the dining room has plenty of TVs and room to spread out. It’s especially good for post-tournament dinners, rainy-day outings, or any time you want pizza with a bit of atmosphere rather than a quick pickup.