01
Best overall pick
Jim's Pizza Box – Milan
Milan Village Center • Classic Small-Town Pizzeria • Crowd-Pleasing Choice For Most Groups
A short drive south of Birmingham, Jim’s in Milan serves up hefty pies with plenty of cheese and a crust that hits the sweet spot between crisp and chewy.
This long-running Milan favorite feels exactly like the hometown pizzeria you want it to be: checkered tables, easygoing service, and locals grabbing carryout by the stack. The menu leans into classic toppings, but the house specialty pizzas and thick-cut pepperoni are what people talk about. It’s an easy choice when you’ve got a mixed group and need something everyone will like.
02
Best for big groups
Jim's Pizza Box – Huron
Huron Marina District • Lively Pizza-And-Sports Bar • Best For Big Game Nights
The Huron outpost of Jim’s pairs the same well-loved pies with a busier, game-day atmosphere near the water.
If you’re coming off the lake or meeting friends halfway from Sandusky and Birmingham, the Huron Jim’s is built for hanging out. Expect big televisions, pitchers, and pans of pizza that can actually keep up with a hungry crowd. Go for shareable appetizers, split a couple of specialty pizzas, and settle in for a long evening of sports and conversation.
03
Best lakeside vibe
Cameo Pizza – Vermilion
Downtown Vermilion Near The River • Casual Lake-Town Slice Shop • Top Pick For Late Evenings By The Water
Cameo in Vermilion is a classic Lake Erie stop where thin, cheesy pies meet a relaxed, by-the-water feel.
Plan this for nights when you want pizza and a stroll along the river or the beach. The crust runs on the thinner, crispier side, with a generous layer of cheese and just the right amount of sauce, making it easy to down an extra slice. It’s a natural fit after a day on the water or a sunset walk along Vermilion’s waterfront.
04
Best college-town slice
Lorenzo's Pizzeria – Oberlin
Downtown Oberlin By The College • Busy College-Town Pizzeria • Ideal For Big Flavors And Creative Toppings
Lorenzo’s in Oberlin delivers foldable slices, hearty whole pies, and plenty of energy thanks to the steady flow of students and locals.
Head to Oberlin when you’re in the mood for something a bit more amped-up than a basic pepperoni. Lorenzo’s slices are substantial, with a chewy New York-style crust and toppings that range from straightforward to fully loaded. Grab a booth, watch the college-town buzz outside, and share a couple of large pies for an easy, affordable night out.
05
Best sit-down Italian
Sorrento Ristorante & Pizzeria – Sheffield Lake
Sheffield Lake Lakeshore Strip • Sit-Down Italian Restaurant With Pizza Focus • Best Choice For A Relaxed, Linger-Over-Dinner Night
Sorrento’s in Sheffield Lake feels more like a classic Italian dining room, but the pizza is good enough to plan the whole meal around.
This is where you go when pizza is the main event but you still want a real night out, with wine, appetizers, and proper table service. The pies lean hearty, with a slightly thicker crust that can stand up to heavier toppings like sausage, banana peppers, and extra cheese. It’s worth the slightly longer drive from Birmingham when you’re celebrating or just not in the mood for another quick carryout box.