01
Best old-school square-cut
Giannamore's Pizza
Lansing, Just South Of Blaine • Cash-Only Takeout Pizza Shop • Local Legend For Ohio Valley-Style Pizza
A no-frills, family-run classic turning out crispy square-cut pies that taste like hometown Friday nights.
Giannamore's is the kind of neighborhood spot where generations of Belmont County families have picked up pizza for ballgames and backyard get-togethers. The crust is on the thinner side and cut into squares, with just enough crisp to stand up to extra pepperoni or sausage. Call ahead during peak hours; the small lot and waiting area can get crowded on weekend evenings.
02
Best for game-day spreads
DeFelice Bros. Pizza
Bridgeport Riverfront • Casual Dine-In And Delivery Pizzeria • Go-To For Big Orders And Variety
A Belmont County standby with generous toppings, lots of specialty pies, and an easy setup for feeding a crowd.
DeFelice Bros. in Bridgeport is a reliable bet when you need a few large pizzas that everyone will be happy with. The menu leans heavy on loaded specialty options, from all-meat to veggie-forward combinations, plus wings and sides to round out a game-day table. It is close enough to Blaine for an easy pickup run, but delivery covers much of the immediate area too.
03
Must-try regional classic
DiCarlo's Pizza
Downtown Wheeling Across The River • Iconic Ohio Valley-Style Pizzeria • Essential Stop For First-Time Visitors
Famous for its square-cut trays with sauce and crust baked hot, then cheese and toppings added to finish.
If you are new to Ohio Valley pizza, DiCarlo's in downtown Wheeling is the place to understand what locals rave about. The pies come out in metal trays, with the crust and sauce baked first and shredded cheese and toppings added while it is still blistering hot. It is a short hop over the river from Blaine and worth the drive for the experience alone.
04
Best sit-down chain option
Pizza Hut
St. Clairsville Retail Corridor • Family-Friendly National Pizzeria • Reliable For Dine-In And Carryout
A familiar choice near the mall where you can linger over pan pizzas, breadsticks, and a casual sit-down meal.
For families who want a predictable, kid-friendly pizza night, the St. Clairsville Pizza Hut is an easy choice. The classic pan crust, wings, and breadsticks hit the spot after shopping or a movie, and there is enough seating to handle youth teams or birthday groups. It is also convenient for carryout when you are driving back toward Blaine along the main strip.
05
Best late-night delivery
Domino's Pizza
St. Clairsville East Side • Delivery-Focused Pizza Chain • Late-Night And Last-Minute Pick
Fast, customizable pies with reliable delivery coverage that reaches Blaine and nearby communities.
When it is late, you are already in for the night, and nobody wants to cook, Domino's in St. Clairsville is the workhorse option. The online ordering makes it easy to customize everything from crust style to sauce and toppings, and the delivery radius comfortably covers much of the Blaine area. It is not fancy, but it is exactly what you want when convenience matters as much as the pizza.